Share PDF

Search documents:
  Report this document  
    Download as PDF   
      Share on Facebook

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 1 of 26

,0 5+( 60,5(' 45$5(4 %$0-3625&9 &1635 )13 5+( 4165+(30 ',453,&5 1) 5(8$4

@` dW5

5

 

 

5

 

 

5

9ZSbfWd ,,

?FKIJFE H<>@FE7C IGFHJI

5

 

E<JMFHB' C)G)

5

 

7^^WYWV ;WTfad)

5

9SeW Ea)5 ,.(.0443

 

5

 

2(5,5,10,0* &3(',5134R 12214,5,10 51

+164510 $45314R /15,10 51 ',4/,44

JZW 7efdaep _af[a` fa V[e_[ee eZag^V TW VW`[WV) JZW 7efdae ZShW [`f[_SfWV' TafZ [` fZW[d _af[a` $Sf -' ,3(,4' -,% S`V [` fZW bdWee' fZSf [X fZW _af[a` [e YdS`fWV fZWk i[^^ fWd_[`SfW fZW[d _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`fsS` SUf fZSf fZWk Va `af VW`k i[^^ ^WSV fa fZW Ua^^SbeW aX fZW EWfiad] S`V ZW`UW fZW VWefdgUf[a` aX _[^^[a`e aX Va^^Sde [` hS^gW' Se iW^^ Se g`W_b^ak_W`f Xad fZW _adW fZS` ,.+ [`V[h[VgS^e iZa_ fZW EWfiad] `ai W_b^ake) JZSf iag^V TW W`ad_age^k iSefWXg^' S`V [e W`f[dW^k g``WUWeeSdk) JZW EWfiad] [e S` abWdSf[`Y Tge[`Wee i[fZ _[^^[a`e aX Va^^Sde [` SeeWfe' S`V egTefS`f[S^^k _adW [` hS^gW) @f ZSe fZW WjU^ge[hW ^aUS^ d[YZfe fa fW^Wh[eW ^[hW YS_We S`V afZWd fWS_(dW^SfWV bdaYdS__[`Y aX fZW ?agefa` 7efdae S`V ?agefa` HaU]Wfe g`VWd ^a`Y(fWd_ Ua`fdSUfe) @f ZSe eUadWe aX [`VWbW`VW`f fZ[dV(bSdfk UdWV[fade) JZW Wh[VW`UW fa TW SVVgUWV Sf fd[S^ i[^^ WefST^[eZ S^^ aX fZ[e' S`V i[^^ S^ea Ua`X[d_ fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fadep h[Wi fZSf S e][^^WV S`V [_bSdf[S^ UZSbfWd ,, fdgefWW' g`VWd fZW egbWdh[e[a` aX fZ[e 9agdf' iag^V ZShW S_b^W faa^e fa dWefdgUfgdW fZW EWfiad] egUUWeeXg^^k S`V bdWeWdhW [fe hS^gW Xad fZW TW`WX[f aX [fe _S`k UdWV[fade' [fe WefSfW' S`V [fe afZWd Ua`ef[fgW`U[We) IZag^V fZ[e USeW TW V[e_[eeWV' fZW abbadfg`[fk fa dWefdgUfgdW fZW EWfiad] i[^^ TW [ddWfd[WhST^k ^aef)

JZW 7efdaep ebWU[X[U SdYg_W`fe Xad V[e_[eeS^ ^SU] _Wd[f) Ja TWY[` i[fZ' iZ[^W fZW 7efdae Va `af WhW` ZShW efS`V[`Y fa Ua`fWef fZW ba[`f' fZ[e USeW SeegdWV^k eSf[eX[We eWUf[a` .+.$T%pe

( , (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 2 of 26

dWcg[dW_W`fe Xad S` [`ha^g`fSdk TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWWV[`Y) JZW USeW iSe X[^WV Tk Xagd UdWV[fade' WSUZ Za^V[`Y S hS^[V bdWbWf[f[a` VWTf' fZW SYYdWYSfW g`eWUgdWV S_ag`f aX iZ[UZ XSd WjUWWVe fZW efSfgfadk fZdWeZa^V aX !,0'.-0) 7`V S` adVWd aX dW^[WX [e iSddS`fWV TWUSgeW' Se fZW Wh[VW`UW i[^^ VW_a`efdSfW' fZW EWfiad] q[e YW`WdS^^k `af bSk[`Y Q[feR VWTfe Se egUZ VWTfe TWUa_W VgW)r ,, K)I)9) t .+.$Z%$,%) JZSf fZW a`^k g`bS[V UdWV[fad [e S` [`e[VWd [e [ddW^WhS`f fa fZW efSfgfadk S`S^ke[e' Se [e fZW XSUf fZSf fZW VWTfe VgW fa fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade iWdW `af bSef VgW' S`V fZSf ea_W ZSV `af WhW` _SfgdWV' Sf fZW f[_W fZW bWf[f[a` iSe X[^WV)

JZW 7efdae S^ea Wdd [` SeeWdf[`Y fZSf fZW bWf[f[a` iSe X[^WV [` TSV XS[fZ) 9agdfe X[`V TSV XS[fZ iZW` S` [`ha^g`fSdk USeW eWdhWe `a hS^[V dWadYS`[lSf[a`S^ bgdbaeW' [)W)' iZW` [f iag^V `af bdWeWdhW hS^gW fZSf iag^V afZWdi[eW TW ^aef) 8k Ua`fdSef' fZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f ZSe Wjb^S[`WV fZSf S USeW [e X[^WV [` YaaV XS[fZ iZWdW fZWdW [e S qYa[`Y Ua`UWd` fa bdWeWdhW'r qW_b^akWWe fa bdafWUf'r S`V qZabW aX dWZST[^[fSf[a`)r /M QE 2ISSKE )QEEJ *EU$ )N$' 224 =)-V ,+13' ,+2. $0fZ 9[d) ,431%)

JZSf [e fZW e[fgSf[a` ZWdW) JZ[e USeW US` bdWeWdhW' Xad fZW TW`WX[f aX UdWV[fade' W_b^akWWe S`V S^^ afZWd efS]WZa^VWde' fZW Ya[`Y(Ua`UWd` hS^gW aX fZW EWfiad] $`af fa _W`f[a` fZW \aTe% fZSf iag^V TW VWefdakWV [X fZW 7efdae fWd_[`SfWV fZW[d _WV[S d[YZfe) Eaf S e[`Y^W USeW U[fWV Tk fZW 7efdae' `ad S`k afZWd USeW aX iZ[UZ fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade SdW SiSdW' V[e_[eeWe S TS`]dgbfUk a` qTSV XS[fZr Ydag`Ve iZWdW' Se ZWdW' fZW VWTfad iSe S` abWdSf[`Y Tge[`Wee fZSf XSUWV fZW bdaebWUf aX ^[cg[VSf[a` [X fZW TS`]dgbfUk iWdW V[e_[eeWV) @` fZ[e dWYSdV' fZW dW^[WX fZW 7efdae eWW] [e ^[fWdS^^k g`bdWUWVW`fWV)

=gdfZWd_adW' Ua`fdSdk fa fZW 7efdaep g`egTefS`f[SfWV SeeWdf[a`e' fZW bWf[f[a` iSe `af S qUa^^ge[hWr WXXadf fa qU[dUg_hW`fr fZW fWd_e aX fZW bSdf[Wep SYdWW_W`fe $fZagYZ WhW` [X [f iWdW fZSf iag^V `af egXX[UW fa WefST^[eZ TSV XS[fZ%) JZWdW [e `a bdah[e[a` [` fZW YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd SYdWW_W`f' ad W^eWiZWdW' fZSf bdWhW`fe EWfiad] UdWV[fade Xda_ Ua__W`U[`Y S` [`ha^g`fSdk

( - (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 3 of 26

TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWWV[`YsWhW` [X fZWk SdW SXX[^[SfWe aX EWfiad] ai`Wde) Ja TW egdW' fZ[e bdaUWWV[`Y _Sk abWdSfW fa fZiSdf fZW 7efdaep SbbSdW`f efdSfWYk aX eSTafSY[`Y fZW EWfiad] Tk T^aU][`Y [fe ST[^[fk fa dS[eW USb[fS^ ad dWhW`gW Xda_ USdd[SYW SddS`YW_W`fe Sf _Sd]Wf fWd_e' S efdSfWYk fZSf iag^V VWbd[hW fZW EWfiad] aX fZW ^[cg[V[fk [f `WWVe fa _WWf [fe aT^[YSf[a`e g`VWd fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f S`V S^^ai fZW 7efdae fa fWd_[`SfW fZSf SYdWW_W`f Xad `a`(bSk_W`f) 8gf fZiSdf[`Y egUZ S efdSfWYk [e `af S` [_bdabWd geW aX TS`]dgbfUk' bSdf[Ug^Sd^k iZWdW' Se ZWdW' TS`]dgbfUk i[^^ bdWeWdhW Xad fZW TW`WX[f aX fZW EWfiad] S`V [fe UdWV[fade fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f fZSf fZW 7efdae SbbSdW`f^k `ai XWW^ [e `af d[UZ W`agYZ fa eg[f fZW_) Ja fZW Ua`fdSdk' a`UW fZW EWfiad] TWUS_W [`ea^hW`f $SYS[`' VgW fa fZW 7efdaep VW^[TWdSfW UZa[UWe%' [fe UdWV[fade iWdW W`f[f^WV fa [`ha]W fZW bdafWUf[a`e aX TS`]dgbfUk fa _S[`fS[` fZW EWfiad] Se S Ya[`Y Ua`UWd`' S`V fZWdWTk _Sj[_[lW fZW dWUahWd[We a` fZW[d ai` U^S[_e)

Ead SdW fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade [_bdabWd^k eWW][`Y fa fS]W ahWd fZW EWfiad]) @` XSUf' fZWk ZShW _ahWV Xad fZW Sbba[`f_W`f aX S V[e[`fWdWefWV fdgefWW bdWU[eW^k fa W`egdW fZSf S` [`VWbW`VW`f fZ[dV bSdfk [e [` b^SUW iZa US` VWfWd_[`W fZW EWfiad]pe g^f[_SfW V[ebae[f[a` i[fZ S `WgfdS^ S`V e[`Y^W(_[`VWV h[Wi faiSdVe _Sj[_[l[`Y [fe hS^gW Xad fZW TW`WX[f aX S^^ aX fZW EWfiad]ep Ua`ef[fgW`U[We) MZ[^W 9a_USef CW`VWd [e bdWbSdWV fa bSdf[U[bSfW [` S`k SgUf[a` bdaUWee S fdgefWW _Sk Za^V' fZW dWeg^f aX fZSf bdaUWee i[^^ TW fZSf fZW EWfiad] $ad [fe SeeWfe% i[^^ i[`V gb [` fZW ZS`Ve aX iZSfWhWd bSdfk hS^gWe [f _aef Z[YZ^k)

=[`S^^k' fZW 7efdaep Ua_b^S[`f fZSf fZW EWfiad] US``af TW dWadYS`[lWV [` TS`]dgbfUk [e TafZ bdW_SfgdW S`V _[eYg[VWV) 7XfWd S` adVWd Xad dW^[WX [e W`fWdWV S`V fZW USeW [e bdaUWWV[`Y' fZW 7efdae i[^^ ZShW fZW[d abbadfg`[fk fa aT\WUf fa S UZSbfWd ,, fdgefWWpe WXXadfe fa Ua`X[d_ S b^S` ad fa eW^^ fZW EWfiad]pe SeeWfe) EafZ[`Y [` fZW[d UgddW`f X[^[`Y' ZaiWhWd' bdah[VWe S TSe[e Xad egUZ S` aT\WUf[a`) JZW 7efdaep Ua`fW`f[a` fZSf fZW TS`]dgbfUk i[^^ XS[^ TWUSgeW fZW ^[_[fWV bSdf`WdeZ[b

( . (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 4 of 26

SYdWW_W`f US``af TW Seeg_WV ad See[Y`WV [e bgll^[`Y' fa eSk fZW ^WSef) JZW EWfiad] [e `af S bSdfk fa fZW bSdf`WdeZ[b SYdWW_W`f) 7 fdgefWW iag^V fZWdWXadW TW ST^W fa bdabaeW S b^S` aX dWadYS`[lSf[a` ad Ua`VgUf S eWUf[a` .1. eS^W aX egTefS`f[S^^k S^^ fZW EWfiad]pe SeeWfe i[fZagf dWYSdV fa fZSf SYdWW_W`f) =[`S^^k' fZW 7efdaep SeeWdf[a` fZSf fZW fWd_e aX fZW[d _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f S`V eWUf[a` .10 aX fZW 9aVW iag^V bdWhW`f S UZSbfWd ,, fdgefWW ad S egTeWcgW`f ai`Wd aX fZW EWfiad] Xda_ WjWdU[e[`Y fZW EWfiad]pe d[YZfe g`VWd fZW SYdWW_W`f [e TW^[WV TafZ Tk fZW SYdWW_W`fpe WjbdWee fWd_e S`V Tk WefST^[eZWV ^Si)

@` eg_' fZWdW [e `a _Wd[f fa fZW 7efdaep SdYg_W`fe) JZW Wh[VW`UW fa TW bdWeW`fWV Sf fd[S^

i[^^ _S]W U^WSd fZSf fZW [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` [e hS^[V S`V eWdhWe S` Sbbdabd[SfW dWadYS`[lSf[a`S^ bgdbaeW) 7` adVWd Xad dW^[WX eZag^V TW W`fWdWV S`V fZW _af[a` fa V[e_[ee eZag^V TW VW`[WV)

,!

5+( 2(5,5,10 4$5,4),(4 4(&5,10 #"#

 

JZW [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` iSe hS^[V^k X[^WV Tk Xagd bWf[f[a`[`Y UdWV[fade' WSUZ aX iZ[UZ

Za^Ve S U^S[_ fZSf [e `af egT\WUf fa Ta`S X[VW V[ebgfW) 7`V fZW bWf[f[a` iSe X[^WV SYS[`ef S VWTfad fZSf' Se aX fZW VSfW aX fZW bWf[f[a`' iSe `af YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk TWUS_W VgW) 7e S _SffWd aX ^Si' a`^k fZW S^^WYWV VWTfads`af fZW 7efdaesZSe efS`V[`Y fa UZS^^W`YW iZWfZWd fZWeW W^W_W`fe SdW _Wf) <hW` [X fZW 7efdae ZSV efS`V[`Y' fZW Wh[VW`UW bdWeW`fWV Sf fd[S^ i[^^ _S]W U^WSd fZSf fZW bWf[f[a` iSe hS^[V^k X[^WV' S`V fZSf S` adVWd Xad dW^[WX eZag^V W`fWd)

$! 5C@ $LMKIL .<>E 4M<H?DHB 5I &C<FF@HB@ 5C@ (HMKQ 1A $H 1K?@K )IK 3@FD@A

IWUf[a` .+.$V% aX fZW 9aVW efSfWe fZSf qQfRZW VWTfad' ad S YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd [` S bSdf`WdeZ[b VWTfad fZSf V[V `af \a[` [` fZW bWf[f[a`' _Sk X[^W S` S`eiWd fa S bWf[f[a` g`VWd fZ[e eWUf[a`)r ,, K)I)9) t .+.$V%) I[_[^Sd^k' =WVWdS^ Hg^W aX 8S`]dgbfUk GdaUWVgdW ,+,, ebWU[X[We fZSf qQfRZW VWTfad `S_WV [` S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` n _Sk Ua`fWef fZW bWf[f[a`)r 9agdfe ZShW dWbWSfWV^k ZW^V fZSf fZWeW bdah[e[a`e bdWU^gVW S`ka`W afZWd fZS` fZW VWTfad $ad S YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd [` S bSdf`WdeZ[b VWTfad% Xda_ Ua`fWef[`Y fZW hS^[V[fk aX S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`) JZW JZ[dV 9[dUg[f' Xad

( / (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 5 of 26

WjS_b^W' efSfWV [` a`W USeW fZSf qIk`WdY[ef[U QS `a`(X[^[`Y UdWV[fadR n [e `af fZW VWTfad' S`V

fZWdWXadW g`VWd ,, K)I)9) t .+.$V% S`V =WVWdS^ Hg^W aX 8S`]dgbfUk GdaUWVgdW ,+,, [f VaWe `af

ZShW fZW d[YZf fa Ua`fWef fZW [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` a` fZW _Wd[fe)r /M QE 7*4" 22)' .1. =) 7bbpj)

32.' 321 $.V 9[d) -+,+%6 ACCNQD /M QE 0ACJ 1AQDNV 6KTLBIMG )N$' /0, =)-V ,-.' ,-4 $0fZ 9[d)

,42,% $q@f ZSe ^a`Y TWW` eWff^WV fZSf 9a`YdWee [` SVabf[`Y fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 7Uf aX ,4.3 dWidafW

n fZW ,343 hWde[a` aX fZW 7Uf fa W^[_[`SfW fZW d[YZf aX S UdWV[fad fa TW ZWSdV [` abbae[f[a` fa S`

SV\gV[USf[a` [` QS` [`ha^g`fSdkR TS`]dgbfUk)r%) JZ[e Ua`U^ge[a` [e S efdS[YZfXadiSdV Sbb^[USf[a`

aX fZW EWOQERRIN TMITR US`a` aX efSfgfadk [`fWdbdWfSf[a`' [)W)' fZSf qfZW WjbdWee[a` aX ea_W QfZ[`YeR

Ua``afWe fZW WjU^ge[a` aX afZWde)r ;EKSECH 9XR$" /MC$ U$ (QXAMS' 2+- =).V -.-' -.3 $0fZ 9[d)

-+,-%) 8k Wjb^[U[f^k bdah[V[`Y fZSf S VWTfad $S`V fZW GEMEQAK bSdf`Wd aX S bSdf`WdeZ[b% _Sk

Ua`fWef S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`' 9a`YdWee _SVW U^WSd fZSf afZWdesegUZ Se fZW 7efdae ZWdWs_Sk

`af Va ea)

JZW 7efdae dWeba`V $Daf) -. `),1% Tk U[f[`Y fia USeWes/M QE 9XMEQGIRSIC ;ECHMNKNGIER"

/MC$' Ea) +2(.,2..(I>A(2' -++2 MC --1/2++ $E);) JWj) 7gY) 1' -++2%' S`V /M QE =ERSEQKEIGH

*EUEKNOLEMS )NQO$' ,/, 8)H) .3 $I);)E)O) ,44-%s[` iZ[UZ S Uagdf egYYWefWV fZSf S bSdfk afZWd

fZS` fZW VWTfad Uag^V Ua`fWef S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` a` fZW Ydag`V fZSf S YahWd`S`UW VWSV^aU]

bdWhW`fWV fZW VWTfad Xda_ Ua`fWef[`Y fZW bWf[f[a`) JZaeW USeWe SdW [`Sbbae[fW S`V Ua`fdSdk fa fZW

ahWdiZW^_[`Y iW[YZf aX SgfZad[fk), JZWk SdW [`Sbbae[fW TWUSgeW `W[fZWd USeW iag^V SgfZad[lW

fZW efdSfWYk fZSf fZW 7efdae eWW] fa VWb^ak ZWdWsfa bWd_[f S _[`ad[fk aX fZW TaSdV aX fZW S^^WYWV

, JZW 7efdae $Daf) -. `),1% S^ea U[fW /M QE )EIKIMG ,AM *IRSQIBTSNQR" /MC$' .2 8)H) 2+, $8S`]d) D);) CS) ,43.%' Xad fZW bdabae[f[a` fZSf S `a`(VWTfad _Sk UZS^^W`YW S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` [X fZWdW [e qS b^S` ad eUZW_W fa SUZ[WhW XdSgV ad afZWd bdaeUd[TWV Ua`VgUf)r JZW Uagdf V[V `af ea Za^V) @f X[def eS[V fZSf STeW`f egUZ S eUZW_W S efaU]Za^VWd Uag^V `af abbaeW S` [`( ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`' S`V fZW` Ua`U^gVWV fZSf WhW` [X fZW efaU]Za^VWd [` fZSf USeW Uag^V abbaeW fZW bWf[f[a`' dW^[WX ef[^^ ZSV fa TW YdS`fWV) 9EE ID$ Sf 2+-) @` S`k WhW`f' Se Wjb^S[`WV [` fZ[e abbae[f[a`' fZW bWf[f[a` ZWdW [`ha^hWe `a egUZ eUZW_W)

( 0 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 6 of 26

VWTfad fa e[^W`UW fZW i[^^ aX fZW _S\ad[fk aX fZW TaSdV' S`V fZW` fa egTef[fgfW [fe _[`ad[fk ha[UW Xad fZSf aX fZW `ai(e[^W`f S^^WYWV VWTfad) 7`V Se fZW _S\ad[fk aX dW^WhS`f USeWe dWUaY`[lWe' `W[fZWd

fZW 8S`]dgbfUk 9aVW `ad fZW 8S`]dgbfUk Hg^We [`U^gVW S` WjUWbf[a` Xad qVWSV^aU]r USeWe)- JZW 7efdae fZWdWXadW ^SU] efS`V[`Y fa UZS^^W`YW fZW hS^[V[fk aX fZW [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`)

=gdfZWd_adW' eWUf[a` .+.$Z% aX fZW 9aVW _S`VSfWe fZSf [X S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` q[e `af f[_W^k Ua`fdahWdfWV' fZW Uagdf eZS^^ adVWd dW^[WX SYS[`ef fZW VWTfad)r ,, K)I)9) t .+.$Z%) ?WdW' iZ[^W fZW 7efdae ZShW _ahWV fa V[e_[ee' `W[fZWd fZW S^^WYWV VWTfad `ad S`k afZWd bSdfk ZSe S`eiWdWV fZW bWf[f[a`) 8WUSgeW fZW bWf[f[a` ZSe fZge `af TWW` qf[_W^k Ua`fdahWdfWV'r S` adVWd aX dW^[WX qeZS^^ W`fWd)r /D6 REE /M QE 0Q$ ,NND 3AQS NF 'QJ$" /MC$' -./ 8)H) /-+' /-, $8S`]d) <);) 7d]) ,444% $iZWdW `a`(VWTfad bgdbadfWV fa S`eiWd fZW bWf[f[a` S`V _ahWV fa V[e_[ee' fZW Uagdf Ua`U^gVWV fZSf qe[`UW fZWdW [e `a dWeba`e[hW b^WSV[`Y X[^WV Tk fZW VWTfad' fZW adVWd Xad dW^[WX _gef TW W`fWdWV XadfZi[fZ'r fZagYZ fZW `a`(VWTfade qSdW `af bdWU^gVWV Xda_ X[^[`Y ad bdaeWUgf[`Y S _af[a` fa V[e_[eer%6 /M QE >AIR /MU$ -QADE 2SD$ <//' /00 8)H) 3.4' 3/1 $8S`]d) ;)E)A) -+,,% $qF`^k fZW S^^WYWV VWTfad _Sk Ua`fWef S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`' [`U^gV[`Y UZS^^W`Y[`Y fZW cgS^[X[USf[a`e aX fZW bWf[f[a`[`Y UdWV[fade) ?WdW' QfZW VWTfadR XS[^WV fa Ua`fWef fZW bWf[f[a` S`V fZW adVWd Xad dW^[WX iSe W`fWdWV Tk VWXSg^f) DahS`fe _Sk `af cgWef[a` fZW bWf[f[a`[`Y UdWV[fade# cgS^[X[USf[a`e)r $U[fSf[a`e a_[ffWV%%)

%! 5C@ 2@MDMDIH 7<L )DF@? %Q $M .@<LM 5CK@@ &K@?DMIKL 7DMC 6H?DLJNM@?

&F<DGL 5C<M (P>@@? 5C@ 4M<MNMIKQ 5CK@LCIF?

<hW` [X fZW 7efdae Uag^V bdabWd^k UZS^^W`YW fZW bWf[f[a`' fZW[d SdYg_W`fe iag^V XS[^) IWUf[a` .+.$T%$,% bdah[VWe fZSf fZdWW ad _adW W`f[f[We _Sk Ua__W`UW S` [`ha^g`fSdk USeW SYS[`ef

- =ad WjS_b^W' fZW 9XMEQGIRSIC Uagdf ebWU[X[US^^k dW^[WV a` eWUf[a` ,+0 aX fZW 9aVW [` VWbSdf[`Y Xda_ fZW WjbdWee ^S`YgSYW aX eWUf[a` .+.) -++2 MC --1/2++ Sf &0) 8gf eWUf[a` ,+0 VaWe `af SgfZad[lW egUZ S VWbSdfgdW) 9EE E$G$' /M QE )NLBTRSINM +MG[G" /MC$' .4, =).V ,4+' --/( --0 $.V) 9[d) -++/%)

( 1 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 7 of 26

S` S^^WYWV VWTfad [X WSUZ W`f[fk Za^Ve S `a`(Ua`f[`YW`f U^S[_ SYS[`ef fZW S^^WYWV VWTfad fZSf [e `af egT\WUf fa Ta`S X[VW V[ebgfW S`V [X fZW fafS^ S_ag`f aX fZaeW W`f[f[Wep g`eWUgdWV U^S[_e [e Sf ^WSef !,0'.-0) JZW 7efdae Va `af VW`k fZSf fZ[e Va^^Sd fZdWeZa^V [e _Wf' [`efWSV Ua`fW`V[`Y fZSf fZWdW SdW `af [` XSUf fZdWW W`f[f[We fZSf Za^V g`V[ebgfWV U^S[_e) JZSf [e [`UaddWUf)

7e S` [`[f[S^ _SffWd' Se fZW bSdfk eWW][`Y V[e_[eeS^' fZW 7efdae ZShW fZW TgdVW` fa VW_a`efdSfW fZSf S Ta`S X[VW V[ebgfW Wj[efe) 9EE /M QE 9ILR' 44/ =)-V -,+' --, $0fZ 9[d) ,44.%) Ja eSf[eXk fZ[e TgdVW`' a`UW fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade ZShW _SVW S OQILA FACIE eZai[`Y fZSf fZWk ZShW eSf[eX[WV fZW dWcg[dW_W`fe aX eWUf[a` .+.' fZW 7efdae _gef dS[eW qRTBRSAMSIAK XSUfgS^ S`V ^WYS^ cgWef[a`er fa eZai fZSf S Ta`S X[VW V[ebgfW Wj[efe) /D$ $W_bZSe[e SVVWV% $[`fWd`S^ cgafSf[a` _Sd]e a_[ffWV%) EW[fZWd fZW 7efdaep S^^WYSf[a`e' `ad fZW Wh[VW`UW fa TW bdWeW`fWV Sf fd[S^' eSf[eXk fZSf TgdVW`)

<SUZ aX fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade ZSe bdah[VWV egXX[U[W`f VWfS[^ STagf [fe U^S[_ SYS[`ef fZW EWfiad] fa eSf[eXk [fe [`[f[S^ TgdVW`' S`V WSUZ [e bdWbSdWV fa bdah[VW XgdfZWd Wh[VW`UW dWYSdV[`Y fZW hS^[V[fk aX [fe U^S[_ Sf fd[S^) JZW XSUf fZSf WSUZ [e S` SXX[^[SfW aX 9a_USef ZSe `a [_bSUf a` fZW hS^[V[fk aX fZW bWf[f[a`) 9EE /M QE 9ILR' 44/ =)-V Sf -,1(-,4 $bSdfk UZS^^W`Y[`Y [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` _gef _WWf fZW efS`VSdV Xad b[WdU[`Y fZW UadbadSfW hW[^siZ[UZ [` S USeW ^[]W fZ[e [`ha^h[`Y S Ua`fdSUfgS^ VWTf dWcg[dWe S eZai[`Y aX XdSgVs[` adVWd fa VWXWSf S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` X[^WV Tk fZdWW eWbSdSfW ^WYS^ W`f[f[We fZSf SdW UadbadSfW SXX[^[SfWe%)

,) )NLCARS 3EDIA )EMSEQ 'MD )NLCARS 9ONQSR4ES )AKIFNQMIA

JZW 7efdae ZShW SeeWdfWV fZSf 9a_USef DWV[S 9W`fWdpe S`V 9a_USef IbadfeEWf 9S^[Xad`[Spe U^S[_e SdW [`hS^[V TWUSgeW fZaeW VWTfe iWdW `af SbbdahWV g`S`[_age^k Tk fZW >W`WdS^ GSdf`Wdpe V[dWUfade' Se S^^WYWV^k dWcg[dWV Tk fZW YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd SYdWW_W`f) JZW hWdk bdah[e[a` fZW 7efdae U[fW' ZaiWhWd' iZ[UZ dWcg[dWe g`S`[_age Ua`eW`f Xad UWdfS[` SXX[^[SfWV fdS`eSUf[a`e' eWfe agf S eWd[We aX WjUWbf[a`e fa fZSf dWcg[dW_W`f) @_badfS`f^k' V[dWUfad g`S`[_[fk

( 2 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 8 of 26

[e MNS dWcg[dWV Xad qS`k fdS`eSUf[a` fZSf' faYWfZWd i[fZ dW^SfWV fdS`eSUf[a`e' $[% [e a` fWd_e `a ^Wee XShadST^W fa n fZW EWfiad] n fZS` n fZW EWfiad] n Uag^V dWSea`ST^k aTfS[` [` fZW _Sd]Wf Xda_ fZ[dV bSdf[We S`V $[[% VaWe `af [`ha^hW _adW fZS` !,++'+++ [` fZW SYYdWYSfW)r 7e fZW fd[S^ Wh[VW`UW i[^^ WefST^[eZ' 9a_USef DWV[Spe S`V 9a_USef 9S^[Xad`[Spe VWTfe XS^^ ecgSdW^k i[fZ[`

fZWeW WjUWbf[a`e).

JZW 7efdae S^ea ba[`f fa S IWbfW_TWd -/' -+,.' SY[`Y dWbadf bdah[VWV Tk 9a_USef IWdh[UWe Se Wh[VW`UW fZSf fZWdW [e S V[ebgfW Se fa 9a_USef DWV[Spe S`V 9a_USef 9S^[Xad`[Spe VWTfe) 7UUadV[`Y fa fZW 7efdae' fZ[e dWbadf eZaie S YW`g[`W V[ebgfW STagf fZW VWTfe aX 9a_USef DWV[S S`V 9a_USef 9S^[Xad`[S TWUSgeW $,% 9a_USef 9S^[Xad`[S VaWe `af SbbWSd a` fZW dWbadf' $-% fZW [`ha[UWe Xad 9a_USef DWV[S fafS^ !2'-/,)-0 dSfZWd fZS` !,+'0,2)0+' S`V $.% Ua__W`fe a` fZW dWbadf [`V[USfW fZSf a`W 9a_USef DWV[S [`ha[UW q`WWVe UaV[`Yr S`V fZW afZWd [e [`UaddWUf) JZW Wh[VW`UW Sf fd[S^' ZaiWhWd' i[^^ U^WSd gb S`k bgdbadfWV Ua`Xge[a` S`V VW_a`efdSfW fZSf S^^ aX fZWeW VWTfe SdW hS^[V) <hW` [X fZWdW iWdW S V[ebgfW STagf a`W aX fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fadep U^S[_e' _adWahWd' fZW dWeg^f iag^V e[_b^k TW fZSf fZWdW SdW SHQEE GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade' `af Xagd) JZSf' aX UagdeW' [e egXX[U[W`f g`VWd fZW 9aVW)

-) )NLCARS 9EQUICER 'MD )NLCARS 2EMDEQ

JZW 7efdae SeeWdf $Daf) ,-(,/% fZSf 9a_USef IWdh[UWep S`V 9a_USef CW`VWdpe U^S[_e SdW [`hS^[V TWUSgeW fZWk iWdW `af VgW S`V ai[`Y Se aX fZW bWf[f[a` VSfW) 8gf fZW 9aVW dWcg[dWe a`^k fZSf S bWf[f[a`[`Y UdWV[fad TW S qZa^VWd aX S U^S[_)r ,, K)I)9) t .+.$T%$,%) 7`V qU^S[_r [e VWX[`WV Se S qd[YZf fa bSk_W`f' VHESHEQ Z RTCH QIGHS IR Z LASTQED ?NQ@ TMLASTQED)r /D$

. IbWU[X[US^^k' fZW fWef[_a`k aX i[f`WeeWe' Ua`fW_badS`Wage [`ha[UWe' S`V fZW EWfiad]pe dWYg^Sd^k(YW`WdSfWV SUUag`f[`Y dWbadfe i[^^ VW_a`efdSfW fZSf TafZ 9a_USef DWV[S S`V 9a_USef 9S^[Xad`[S bdah[VWV eWdh[UWe fa fZW EWfiad] g`VWd efS`VSdV Ua__WdU[S^ fWd_e) JZW Wh[VW`UW i[^^ S^ea eZai fZSf fZWeW AD HNC fdS`eSUf[a`e $faYWfZWd' [` WSUZ USeW' i[fZ S`k qdW^SfWV fdS`eSUf[a`er% XW^^ TW^ai fZW !,++'+++ fZdWeZa^V' S`V fZWdWXadW fZSf fZW g`S`[_age(Ua`eW`f bdah[e[a` aX fZW YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd SYdWW_W`f a` iZ[UZ fZW 7efdae dW^k VaWe `af Sbb^k)

( 3 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 9 of 26

t ,+,$0% $W_bZSe[e SVVWV%)/ @f [e fZWdWXadW [ddW^WhS`f iZWfZWd 9a_USef IWdh[UWep S`V 9a_USef

CW`VWdpe U^S[_e _SfgdWV TWXadW ad SXfWd fZW bWf[f[a` VSfW)

JZW 7efdae S^ea SeeWdf fZSf 9a_USef CW`VWd eZag^V `af Uag`f faiSdV eWUf[a` .+.$T%pe

`g_Wdae[fk dWcg[dW_W`f TWUSgeW [fe U^S[_ [e eWUgdWV) JZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f ZSe ZW^V' ZaiWhWd' fZSf

qS` W`f[fk fZSf ZSe S eWUgdWV U^S[_ LAX Uag`f faiSdV QfZSfR dWcg[dW_W`f bdah[VWV fZW g`eWUgdWV

U^S[_e _WWf fZW _[`[_g_ fZdWeZa^V S_ag`f)r /M QE 9ILR' 44/ =)-V Sf --, $W_bZSe[e SVVWV%)

@`VWWV' [f iag^V SbbWSd fZSf EUEQX Uagdf fa SVVdWee fZW [eegW ZSe ea ZW^V' Ua`X[d_[`Y fZW U^Sd[fk aX

fZW efSfgfadk ^S`YgSYW)0 JZW 7efdae bdah[VW `a ^WY[f[_SfW dWSea`' S`V Tk VWX[`[f[a` US` aXXWd `a

bdWUWVW`f' Xad fZW 9agdf fa VWbSdf Xda_ fZ[e g`[Xad_ ^[`W aX SgfZad[fk)

&!

5C@ 0@MOIKE ,L *@H@K<FFQ 0IM 2<QDHB ,ML '@=ML $L 5C@Q %@>IG@ 'N@

JZW 7efdae XSdW `a TWffWd [` SeeWdf[`Y fZSf dW^[WX [e g`iSddS`fWV TWUSgeW fZW EWfiad] [e [`

XSUf YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk TWUa_W VgW) 9EE ,, K)I)9) t .+.$Z%$,%) Ja TWY[` i[fZ'

fZW 7efdae ebW`V _gUZ aX fZW[d SdYg_W`f a` iZWfZWd fZW EWfiad] [e bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe fa fZW

GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade) 9EE Daf) ,2(,3) JZSf [e `af fZW [eegW) JZW cgWef[a` g`VWd eWUf[a`

.+.$Z%$,% [e iZWfZWd fZW EWfiad] [e YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe ahWdS^^) 7`V fZW S`eiWd [e `a)

9agdfe [` fZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f Ua`e[VWd Xagd XSUfade fa VWfWd_[`W iZWfZWd S VWTfad [e bSk[`Y

[fe VWTfe Se fZWk Ua_W VgW5 q$,% fZW `g_TWd aX g`bS[V U^S[_e6 $-% fZW S_ag`f aX egUZ U^S[_e6 $.%

fZW _SfWd[S^[fk aX fZW `a`(bSk_W`fe6 S`V $/% fZW VWTfadpe ahWdS^^ Ua`VgUf [` ZWd X[`S`U[S^ SXXS[de)r

/ 9EE AKRN 9FCC@<H FE 87EBHKGJ9O v .+.)+4 $q7 UdWV[fad Za^Ve S U^S[_ WhW` [X fZW U^S[_ [e `af VgW TWUSgeW U^S[_e US` TW g`_SfgdWV)r%6 /M QE =IM#9TL 9ONQSR" /MC$' ,/ 8)H) .34' .4. $8S`]d) ;) 9a``) ,43,%)

0 9EE" E$G$" 6AQADIRE .NSEK )NQO$ U$ (AMJ NF 4NUA 9CNSIA' 3/- =)-V /2' /4(0+ $.V 9[d) ,433%6 /M QE 'KKEM#3AIM 'RRNCR$ 2SD$ 6[RHIO' --. 8)H) 04' 1, $8)7)G) -V 9[d) ,443%6 REE AKRN - 9FCC@<H FE 87EBHKGJ9O v .+.)+3 $,0fZ WV) ,44.%) 'CCNQD /M QE +UEQESS' ,23 8)H) ,.-' ,/- $8S`]d) E);) FZ[a) ,44/%6 /M QE 1MNSH' ,13 8)H) .,,' .,0 $8S`]d) ;)I)9) ,44/%6 /M QE )QABSQEE'

.- 8)H) 3.2' 3.4 $8S`]d) <);) JW``) ,43.%6 @` dW =aj' Ea) 4.(Uh(022.' ,44/ MC /3/041' &. $E);) @^^) IWbf) -' ,44/%)

( 4 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 10 of 26

/M QE 9LISH' /,0 8)H) ---' -., $8S`]d) E);) JWj) -++4% $cgaf[`Y /M QE 3NRR' -/4 8)H) /,,' /-- $8S`]d) E);) JWj) -+++%%) 9agdfe [` fZ[e V[efd[Uf' ZaiWhWd' ZShW S^ea dW\WUfWV fZW SdYg_W`f fZSf S _S\ad[fk aX S VWTfadep VWTfe _gef TW g`bS[V Xad S VWTfad fa TW qYW`WdS^^kr `af bSk[`Y VWTfe Se fZWk Ua_W VgW) HSfZWd' qYW`WdS^^k `af bSk[`Y VWTfe [`U^gVWe dWYg^Sd^k _[ee[`Y S e[Y`[X[US`f `g_TWd aX bSk_W`fe fa UdWV[fade ad dWYg^Sd^k _[ee[`Y bSk_W`fe iZ[UZ SdW e[Y`[X[US`f [` S_ag`f [` dW^Sf[a` fa fZW e[lW aX fZW VWTfadpe abWdSf[a`)r /M QE 'KK 3EDIA 6QNOR$" /MC$' 0 8)H) ,-1' ,/. $8S`]d) I);) JWj) ,43+%' AFF[D' 1/1 =)-V ,4. $0fZ 9[d) ,43,% $bWd Ugd[S_%) =gdfZWd_adW' Uagdfe [` fZ[e V[efd[Uf $Se W^eWiZWdW% ZShW ZW^V fZSf S e[`Y^W g`bS[V VWTf [e egXX[U[W`f fa WefST^[eZ fZSf S VWTfad [e YW`WdS^^k `af bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk Ua_W VgW) 9EE /M QE 'QQINKA +MEQGX )NQO$' 2/ 8)H) 23/' 24+ $I);) JWj) ,432% $Wjb^S[`[`Y fZSf q[X' SXfWd fZW ;WTfadep bdWeW`fSf[a`' [f SbbWSde fZSf QS UWdfS[`R VWTf [e ea egTefS`f[S^ Se Ua_bSdWV i[fZ S`k afZWd agfefS`V[`Y VWTfe' fZW` [f S^a`W iag^V Ua`ef[fgfW egXX[U[W`f Wh[VW`UW fa WefST^[eZ fZW YW`WdS^^k(`af(bSk[`Y efS`VSdVr%6 'IGMEQ U$ 3C3IKKAM' Ea) ,,(/2+-4(;DC(2' -+,. MC -//0+/- $8S`]d) E);) JWj) Ag`W /' -+,.% $qfZW ^Si n [` fZ[e V[efd[Uf [e U^WSd5 S` S^^WYWV VWTfadpe XS[^gdW fa VWS^ i[fZ S e[`Y^W' bd[`U[bS^ VWTf [e egXX[U[W`f fa egbbadf S VWfWd_[`Sf[a` fZSf fZW S^^WYWV VWTfad [e `af _WWf[`Y [fe aT^[YSf[a`e Se fZWk

Ua_W VgWr%)1

JZW EWfiad]pe ^SdYWef g`eWUgdWV VWTf' Tk XSd' [e fZW bSk_W`f VgW fa fZW 7efdae g`VWd fZW fZW[d _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f) 7e aX fZW bWf[f[a` VSfW' fZW EWfiad] ZSV XS[^WV fa _S]W eUZWVg^WV bSk_W`fe a` fZ[e VWTf Xad fia Ua`eWUgf[hW _a`fZesS`V ZSe e[`UW _[eeWV S fZ[dV bSk_W`f) JZ[e [e TWUSgeW EACH aX fZWeW bSk_W`fe aX XSd WjUWWVe fZW aX ^[cg[V[fk a` fZW

1 9EE AKRN /M QE )NMCQESE 6TLOIMG 9EQU$ /MC$' 4/. =)-V 1-2 $1fZ 9[d) ,44,% $Za^V[`Y fZSf VWTfad iSe `af bSk[`Y VWTfe Se fZWk TWUS_W VgW iZWdW VWTfad iSe [` VWXSg^f a` S^^ aX [fe VWTf fa a`W UdWV[fad%6 /M QE +TQN#'L$ 2NDGIMG )NQO$' .02 8)H) 2++' 2,. $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -++2% $qJZW XS[^gdW fa bSk \gef a`W e[Y`[X[US`f UdWV[fad US` egbbadf S X[`V[`Y fZSf fZW VWTfad [e YW`WdS^^k `af bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe)r $U[fSf[a`e a_[ffWV%%)

( ,+ (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 11 of 26

EWfiad]pe TS^S`UW eZWWf Se aX fZW bWf[f[a` VSfW) DadWahWd' fZWeW _[eeWV bSk_W`fe SUUag`fWV Xad

fZW _S\ad[fk aX fZW EWfiad]pe _a`fZ^k SUUag`fe bSkST^W) 7e Uagdfe dagf[`W^k dWUaY`[lW' S`

W`f[fk fZSf XS[^e fa bSk _aef aX iZSf [f aiWe S`V ZSe [`egXX[U[W`f Xg`Ve fa _S]W fZaeW bSk_W`fe'

cgS^[X[We Se qYW`WdS^^k `af bSk[`Yr [fe VWTfe) 9EE 'KK 3EDIA 6QNOR$' 0 8)H) Sf ,/. $qYW`WdS^^k `af

bSk[`Y VWTfe [`U^gVWe n dWYg^Sd^k _[ee[`Y bSk_W`fe iZ[UZ SdW e[Y`[X[US`f [` S_ag`f [` dW^Sf[a`

fa fZW e[lW aX fZW VWTfadpe abWdSf[a`r%6 /M QE 9LISH' /,0 8)H) Sf -., $qQJRZW S^^WYWV VWTfad _Sk

`af TW oYW`WdS^^kp bSk[`Y Z[e VWTfe Se fZWk Ua_W VgW iZW` ZW [e n `af bSk[`Y S XWi UdWV[fade

fZSf _S]W gb fZW Tg^] aX Z[e VWTfe)r%)2

JZSf fZW g`bS[V VWTf [e aiWV fa fZW 7efdae [e [ddW^WhS`f fa iZWfZWd fZW EWfiad] _WWfe fZW

q`af(YW`WdS^^k(bSk[`Yr efS`VSdV) @` XSUf' Uagdfe ZShW ZW^V fZSf WhW` S` [`e[VWdpe WjbdWee VWXWddS^

ad XadTWSdS`UW aX VWTfesiZ[UZ fZW 7efdae ZShW `af WhW` Va`WsqVaWe `af bdWU^gVW fZW `a`(

bSk_W`f aX fZWeW VWTfe Xda_ TW[`Y Ua`e[VWdWV [` SeUWdfS[`[`Y iZWfZWd S` S^^WYWV VWTfad [e

YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se egUZ TWUa_W VgW)r /M QE /MS[K ;EKDASA )NQO$' ,- 8)H) 324' 33-

$8S`]d) ;) EWh) ,43,%) 7e a`W TS`]dgbfUk Uagdf [` fZ[e V[efd[Uf Wjb^S[`WV5

qQ=Rad QS` [`e[VWdR fa eSk fZSf ZW S`V Z[e SXX[^[SfWe SdW i[^^[`Y fa ZShW bSk_W`fe VWXWddWV S`V fZSf fZWdWXadW QfZW S^^WYWV VWTfadR [e YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VgW VWTf _WS`e fZSf fZW afZWd UdWV[fade iZa ZShW `af TWW` bS[V _gef TWSd fZW SVV[f[a`S^ d[e] fZSf QfZW S^^WYWV VWTfadpeR bae[f[a` _[YZf XgdfZWd VWfWd[adSfW)n JZW XSUf fZSf S VWTfad [e `af bSk[`Y q[`e[VWder iZa ZSbbW` fa TW UdWV[fade n VaWe `af `WYSfW fZW XSUf fZSf fZW VWTfad iSe `af bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk TWUS_W VgW)

'KK 3EDIA 6QNOR$' 0 8)H) Sf ,/2(/3)3

2 9EE AKRN /M QE -AQKAMD )NAK ! 3IMIMG )N$' 12 8)H) 0,/' 0-, $8S`]d) M);) 7d]) ,431% $YW`WdS^^k(`af(bSk[`Y efS`VSdV _Wf iZWdW g`bS[V VWTf WjUWWVWV 0+ bWdUW`f aX VWTfadpe agfefS`V[`Y ^[ST[^[f[We%6 .IKK U$ )AQGIKK" /MC$' 3 8)H) 224' 23+(3, $;) D[``) ,43,% $e[_[^Sd%6 /M QE 'LAMAS' .-, 8)H) .+' .4(/+ $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -++0% $e[_[^Sd%)

3 9EE AKRN /M QE 3IDVERS 6QNCERRIMG )N$' /, 8)H) 4+' ,+, $8S`]d) ;)E);) ,43/%' QEU[D NM NSHEQ GQNTMDR RTB MNL$ (ARIM +KEC$ 6NVEQ )N#NO$ U$ 3IDVERS 6QNCERRIMG )N$' /2 8)H) 4+.

$n)Ua`f[`gWV%

( ,, (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 12 of 26

@` eZadf' Ua`e[VWdSf[a` aX fZW _[eeWV bSk_W`fe fa fZW 7efdae [e dWcg[dWV g`VWd eWUf[a`

.+.$Z%$,%) F`UW fZaeW bSk_W`fe SdW Ua`e[VWdWV' fZWdW [e `a SdYg_W`f fZSf fZW EWfiad] [e `af

YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk Ua_W VgW)

C[]Wi[eW' Uagdfe ZShW dW\WUfWV fZW 7efdaep bdabae[f[a` fZSf S` S^^WYWV aXXWd fa TSU]efab

aT^[YSf[a`e fa fZ[dV(bSdfk UdWV[fade `WYSfWe S X[`V[`Y fZSf S` S^^WYWV VWTfad [e `af bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe)

4 ,IQRS' Se eWf XadfZ STahW' [f [e [ddW^WhS`f iZWfZWd fZW EWfiad] [e bSk[`Y [fe e_S^^' fZ[dV(bSdfk

U^S[_e' ad WhW` iZWfZWd [f [e bSk[`Y fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fadep U^S[_e) JZWeW bSk_W`f

aT^[YSf[a`e SdW f[`k dW^Sf[hW fa fZW VWTf VgW S`V ai[`Y fa fZW 7efdae) 9ECNMD' qQbRSk_W`fe aX QSR

VWTfadpe aT^[YSf[a`e Tk S fZ[dV bSdfk SdW `af fdWSfWV Se bSk_W`f Tk fZW VWTfad [feW^X) 7VV[f[a`S^

USeZ [`Xge[a`e Xda_ fZ[dV bSdfk bSk_W`fe [e `af Wh[VW`UW fZSf S VWTfad iSe bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se

fZWk TWUa_W VgW)r /M QE 8ED 8NCJ 8IG &%&" 2SD$' .42 8)H) 0/0' -++3 8S`]d) C<N@I ,/-.' &3

$8)7)G) ,+fZ 9[d) -++3% $U[f[`Y USeWe%) ,IMAKKX' S^fZagYZ fZW 7efdae ZShW NFFEQED fa TSU]efab

UWdfS[` fZ[dV(bSdfk aT^[YSf[a`e' fZWk ZShW `af SUfgS^^k Ua`fd[TgfWV Xg`Ve fa fZW EWfiad]' S`V

Uagdfe Va `af Ua`e[VWd Xg`Ve dWUW[hWV SXfWd fZW bWf[f[a` VSfW) IEE /M QE 0NMER ! 3C)KAIM" 226'

-2, 8)H) /2.' /3,(/3- $8S`]d) M);) GS) -++,%6 'KK 3EDIA 6QNOR$' 0 8)H) Sf ,//),+

$Ua`f[`gWVn)%

$;)E);) ,43/%6 /M QE ,NND -AKKEQX AS <AKKEXBQNNJ' --- 8)H) /3+' /33(/34 $8S`]d) M);) GS) ,443%)

4 JZW 7efdae SeeWdf $Daf) Sf ,/ `) ,-% fZSf q9a_USefr ZSe ^[]Wi[eW aXXWdWV fa qTSU]efabr fZ[dV(bSdfk U^S[_e) JZSf [e `af UaddWUf) 9a_USef CW`VWd ZSe efSfWV fZSf [f iag^V TW i[^^[`Y fa _S]W S T[V [` TS`]dgbfUk Xad fZW EWfiad] ad egTefS`f[S^^k S^^ aX [fe SeeWfe' iZ[UZ 9a_USef CW`VWd TW^[WhWe qiag^V ^[]W^k ^WSV fa Xg^^ bSk_W`f aX S^^ bdW(bWf[f[a` UdWV[fadep U^S[_e S`V S^^ dWSea`ST^k XadWeWWST^W SV_[`[efdSf[hW WjbW`eWe)r GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade JdgefWW Daf) Sf . $v2%)

,+ JZW 7efdae S^ea ba[`f $Daf) -% fa 9a_USef CW`VWdpe efSfW_W`f fZSf [f iag^V TW bdWbSdWV fa bSdf[U[bSfW [` S TS`]dgbfUk SgUf[a` Xad fZW EWfiad] ad [fe SeeWfe' S`V fa aXXWd S` S_ag`f egXX[U[W`f fa bSk UdWV[fade [` Xg^^) JZSf efSfW_W`f VaWe `af dW_afW^k eZai fZSf fZW EWfiad] iSe YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk TWUS_W VgW Se aX fZW bWf[f[a` VSfW)

( ,- (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 13 of 26

@` eg_' ahWd fZW bSef eWhWdS^ _a`fZe fZW S_ag`fe VgW fa fZW 7efdae g`VWd fZW[d _WV[S

d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f ZShW dWbdWeW`fWV fZW ahWdiZW^_[`Y _S\ad[fk aX fZW EWfiad]pe bSkST^We) JZW EWfiad] ZSe XS[^WV fa _S]W fZaeW bSk_W`fe fa fZW 7efdae $TWUSgeW [f ^SU]e fZW USeZ fa Va ea%) JZSf [e S fWjfTaa] VWX[`[f[a` aX S VWTfad `af YW`WdS^^k bSk[`Y [fe VWTfe Se fZWk Ua_W VgW)

,,!

5+( 2(5,5,10 7$4 ),.(' ,0 *11' )$,5+

 

JZW 7efdae ^[]Wi[eW Ya SefdSk [` UZSdY[`Y fZSf fZW bWf[f[a` iSe X[^WV [` TSV XS[fZ) JZW

Wh[VW`UW Sf fd[S^ i[^^ WefST^[eZ' Se fZW 7efdaep _af[a` WjbdWee^k SU]`ai^WVYWe' fZSf fZW 7efdae dWXgeWV fa bWd_[f fZW EWfiad] fa W`fWd [`fa USdd[SYW SYdWW_W`fe Sf _Sd]Wf(U^WSd[`Y bd[UWe' S`V dW\WUfWV hSd[age bdabaeS^e fZSf iag^V ZShW bdah[VWV VWTf ad Wcg[fk Xg`V[`Y $ad TafZ% fa fZW EWfiad]) 7e S dWeg^f' fZW EWfiad] ^SU]WV fZW dWhW`gW [f `WWVWV fa bSk [fe T[^^e' S`V fZge VWXSg^fWV g`VWd fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f) JZW 7efdae WXXWUf[hW^k SV_[f fZSf fZW[d [`fW`f[a` [e fa fWd_[`SfW fZW SYdWW_W`f $iZ[UZ fZWk [`f[_SfW [e a` fWd_e faa XShadST^W fa fZW EWfiad]%' fZge bdWU[b[fSf[`Y fZW EWfiad]pe Ua^^SbeW) 7f TWef' fZW EWfiad]pe dW_S[`[`Y SeeWfe iag^V TW ea^V [` S X[dW eS^W) 7^^ aX [fe ,.+ W_b^akWWe i[^^ ^aeW fZW[d \aTe)

JZW Xg`VS_W`fS^ bgdbaeW aX UZSbfWd ,, [e fa bdWhW`f egUZ S dWeg^f) 7`V [f iSe fa bdWhW`f bdWU[eW^k fZSf dWeg^f fZSf fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade X[^WV fZ[e USeW) JZW 7efdaep `ahW^ SdYg_W`fs fZSf [f [e S` [_bdabWd geW aX 9ZSbfWd ,, fa eWW] fa dWadYS`[lW S VWTfad fZSf fZWk iag^V bdWXWd fa eWW ^[cg[VSfWVsYWfe [f WjSUf^k TSU]iSdVe) 7 UZSbfWd ,, TS`]dgbfUk bWf[f[a` [e X[^WV [` YaaV XS[fZ [X [f eWdhWe S ^WY[f[_SfW dWadYS`[lSf[a`S^ bgdbaeW) 9EE /M QE /MSEGQASED ;EKECNL +WOQERR" /MC$'

.3/ =).V ,+3' ,-4 $.V 9[d) -++/% $qJa TW X[^WV [` YaaV XS[fZ' S bWf[f[a` n _gef eWW] fa UdWSfW ad bdWeWdhW ea_W hS^gW fZSf iag^V afZWdi[eW TW ^aef n agfe[VW aX TS`]dgbfUk)r%) ?WdW' fZW TS`](

( ,. (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 14 of 26

dgbfUk i[^^ bdWeWdhW fZW EWfiad]pe Ya[`Y(Ua`UWd` hS^gW' iZ[UZ iag^V afZWdi[eW TW VWefdakWV),,

JZSf [e S Ua_b^WfW S`eiWd fa fZW 7efdaep Ua`fW`f[a`e) @`VWWV' iZ[^W fZW 7efdaep _af[a` [e

^[TWdS^^k eS^fWV i[fZ g`egbbadfWV $S`V g`fdgW% SUUgeSf[a`e STagf 9a_USefpe _af[hWe S`V

egbbaeWV TSV XS[fZ' `a`W aX fZaeW SUUgeSf[a`e UZS`YWe fZW V[ebae[f[hW ba[`f5 @X fZ[e TS`]dgbfUk

USeW YaWe XadiSdV' fZW Tge[`Wee US` egdh[hW6 [X fZW USeW [e V[e_[eeWV' [f i[^^ `af),-

@` S`k WhW`f' `a`W aX fZW [`V[U[S aX S TSV(XS[fZ X[^[`Y [e bdWeW`f ZWdW) 7e S fZdWeZa^V

_SffWd' S TS`]dgbfUk bWf[f[a` eZag^V TW V[e_[eeWV Xad ^SU] aX YaaV XS[fZ qa`^k ebSd[`Y^k S`V i[fZ

YdWSf USgf[a`)r /M QE -EM$ -QNVSH 6QNOR$' /+4 8)H) /.' 01 $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -++4% $U[f[`Y

USeWe%) 7`V [f [e fZW 7efdaep TgdVW` fa bdahW fZSf fZW efS`VSdVe Xad V[e_[eeS^ ZShW TWW` _Wf) 9EE

/M QE ;ICHX +KEC$ )N$' ..- 8)H) .1/' .2, $8S`]d) E);) @aiS -++0% $qJZWdW [e S bdWeg_bf[a` fZSf

bWf[f[a`[`Y UdWV[fade g`VWd t .+. SUf [` YaaV XS[fZ) JZge' fZW QUZS^^W`YWdR ZSe fZW TgdVW` aX

,, JZW _SY`[fgVW aX fZW EWfiad] Se S Ya[`Y Ua`UWd`' S`V fZW WUa`a_[U V[edgbf[a` fZSf [fe ^[cg[VSf[a` iag^V USgeW' [e YdWSfWd fZS` _Sk TW SbbSdW`f Xda_ S ^[ef[`Y aX fZW EWfiad]pe fZ[dV( bSdfk UdWV[fade) 9a_USef SXX[^[SfWe SdW [`ha^hWV [` fZW _S`SYW_W`f S`V abWdSf[a` aX S `g_TWd aX dWY[a`S^ ebadfe `Wfiad]e) 7e bdah[VWV Xad [` 9a_USef IWdh[UWep SYdWW_W`f i[fZ fZW EWfiad]' fZaeW 9a_USef SXX[^[SfWe _Sk bgdUZSeW' Se fZWk aXfW` Va' UWdfS[` eWdh[UWe Xda_ fZ[dV bSdf[We Xad geW Tk [`V[h[VgS^ dWY[a`S^ ebadfe `Wfiad]e S`V S^^aUSfW fZW SeeaU[SfWV Uaefe fa fZW dWebWUf[hW `Wfiad]e) MZ[^W fZW 9a_USef SXX[^[SfWe' dSfZWd fZS` fZW EWfiad]' _Sk ZShW V[dWUf ^[ST[^[fk fa fZaeW UdWV[fade' fZW WUa`a_[U ^aeeWe S`V V[edgbf[a` fZSf iag^V TW USgeWV Tk fZW EWfiad]pe ^[cg[VSf[a` [e `a ^Wee fZS` [f iag^V TW ZSV fZaeW fZ[dV bSdf[We Ua`fdSUfWV V[dWUf^k i[fZ fZW EWfiad])

,- F`W WjS_b^W aX fZW 7efdaep SUUgeSf[a`e [e fZW[d SeeWdf[a` $Daf) -.% fZSf qfZW EWfiad]pe SeeWfe n Va `af [`U^gVW fZW 7efdaep _WV[S d[YZfe'r S`V fZSf 9a_USef CW`VWd [e ge[`Y qfZW TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWee Se S bdajk Xad S eWUgdWV [`fWdWef [` fZW _WV[S d[YZfe fZSf [f XS[^WV fa aTfS[` Sf fZW `WYaf[Sf[`Y fST^W)r JZ[e [e _[e^WSV[`Y Sf TWef) JZWdW US` TW `a V[ebgfW' TSeWV a` fZW dW^WhS`f VaUg_W`fe S^a`W' fZSf fZW EWfiad]pe SeeWfe Va [`U^gVW fZW ^[UW`eW fa fZW _WV[S d[YZfe YdS`fWV Tk fZW 7efdae g`VWd fZW fWd_e aX fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f $[)W)' fZW d[YZfe YdS`fWV fa fZW EWfiad] Tk fZW 7efdae fa TdaSVUSef fZW 7efdaep YS_We% S`V fZSf 9a_USef CW`VWd ZSe S eWUgdWV [`fWdWef [` fZW EWfiad]pe' [)W)' fZW TaddaiWdpe' d[YZfe g`VWd fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f) =gdfZWd_adW' 9a_USef CW`VWd [e `af qge[`Y fZW TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWee Se S bdajk Xad S eWUgdWV [`fWdWef [` fZW _WV[S d[YZfe fZSf [f XS[^WV fa aTfS[` Sf fZW `WYaf[Sf[`Y fST^W)r Ja fZW Ua`fdSdk' 9a_USef CW`VWd [e Va[`Y WjSUf^k fZW abbae[fWs[f [e ge[`Y fZW TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWee fa bdWeWdhW fZW hS^gW aX [fe Ua^^SfWdS^)

( ,/ (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 15 of 26

bdah[`Y TSV XS[fZ Tk S bdWba`VWdS`UW aX fZW Wh[VW`UW)r $U[f[`Y /M QE (AXRHNQE =IQE 6QNDR$ )NQO$' -+4 =).V ,++' ,+0 $-V 9[d) -+++% $afZWd U[fSf[a`e a_[ffWV%%) JZWk US``af USddk fZSf TgdVW`)

JZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f ZSe Wjb^S[`WV fZSf S bWf[f[a` _Sk TW [` TSV XS[fZ iZWdW qfZWdW [e `a Ya[`Y Ua`UWd` fa bdWeWdhW' fZWdW SdW `a W_b^akWWe fa bdafWUf' S`V fZWdW [e `a ZabW aX dW( ZST[^[fSf[a`'r [)W)' q[X fZWdW [e `af S bafW`f[S^^k h[ST^W Tge[`Wee [` b^SUW iadfZk aX bdafWUf[a`)r /M QE 2ISSKE )QEEJ' 224 =)-V Sf ,+2.6 ACCNQD" E$G$' /M QE 9-2 )AQBNM )NQO$' -++ =).V ,0/' ,10 $.V 9[d) ,444% $qUSeWe Za^V fZSf S 9ZSbfWd ,, bWf[f[a` [e `af X[^WV [` YaaV XS[fZ g`^Wee [f eWdhWe S hS^[V dWadYS`[lSf[a`S^ bgdbaeWr%) @` egUZ USeWe' Uagdfe _Sk Ua`U^gVW fZSf fZW TS`]dgbfUk iSe X[^WV MNS fa SUZ[WhW S` Sbbdabd[SfW dWadYS`[lSf[a`S^ bgdbaeW' Tgf dSfZWd fa YS[` S` [_bdabWd efdSfWY[U SVhS`fSYW) 9EE /M QE (QAYNR +LEQGEMCX 6HXRICIAMR 'RR[M" 6$'$' /2, =) 7bbpj .4.' .4/ $0fZ 9[d) -+,-% $bWd Ugd[S_% $SXX[d_[`Y TSV(XS[fZ V[e_[eeS^ iZWdW qfZW TS`]dgbfUk Uagdf Ua`U^gVWV fZSf n fZW NMKX bgdbaeW aX 8<G7pe X[^[`Y iSe fa YS[` Ua`fda^ aX fZW efSfW(Uagdf U^S[_er $W_bZSe[e SVVWV%%6 /M QE 'MSEKNOE ;ECHR$" /MC$' /., =) 7bbpj -2-' -20 $0fZ 9[d) -+,,% $bWd Ugd[S_%6 /M QE

.TLBKE 6KACE 0NIMS <EMSTQE' 4.1 =)-V 3,/' 3,3 $0fZ 9[d) ,44,%) 8gf `afZ[`Y aX fZW eadf [e bdWeW`f ZWdW' iZWdW fZWdW IR S Ya[`Y Ua`UWd`' fZWdW AQE W_b^akWWe iZa i[^^ ^aeW fZW[d \aTe S`V UdWV[fade iZa i[^^ Ya g`bS[V [X fZW Tge[`Wee eZgffWde [fe Vaade' S`V fZWdW IR ZabW aX dWadYS`[lSf[a`s[X S fdgefWW [e Sbba[`fWV iZa US` bgf fZW Tge[`Wee [` fZW ZS`Ve aX iZaWhWd hS^gWe [f _aef Z[YZ^k S`V US` bgf [f fa [fe TWef geW)

JZW 7efdae SdYgW' ZaiWhWd' fZSf fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade [_bdabWd^k X[^WV Xad TS`]dgbfUk fa bdWhW`f fZW 7efdae Xda_ fWd_[`Sf[`Y fZW[d _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f i[fZ fZW EWfiad]) 8gf fZSf [e `af S` [_bdabWd bgdbaeW) 7e fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade Wjb^S[`WV [` fZW[d _af[a` Xad Sbba[`f_W`f aX S fdgefWW $v /,%' [X fZW d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f iWdW fWd_[`SfWV fZW EWfiad] iag^V ^aeW a`W aX [fe _aef [_badfS`f S`V hS^gST^W SeeWfes[` WjUZS`YW Xad `afZ[`Y) 7ha[V[`Y fZSf dWeg^f

( ,0 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 16 of 26

iag^V fZge qbdWeWdhW ea_W hS^gW fZSf iag^V afZWdi[eW TW ^aef n agfe[VW aX TS`]dgbfUk)r /M QE /MSEGQASED ;EKECNL' .3/ =).V Sf ,-46 REE AKRN" E$G$' /M QE ;HE 9PTAQE AS ,AKKIMG 8TM 22)' /2- 8)H) ..2' ./0 $8S`]d) E);) M) LS) -+,,% $dW\WUf[`Y TSV(XS[fZ U^S[_ iZWdW fZW VWTfad iSe q[`USbST^W aX SUZ[Wh[`Y [fe Tge[`Wee aT\WUf[hWeQ' TRgf fZWdW _Sk TW hS^gW fa TW eS^hSYWV fZdagYZ TS`]dgbfUkr%)

Ead [e fZWdW S`k _Wd[f fa fZW 7efdaep dWbWSfWV SeeWdf[a` fZSf 9a_USef [e [_bdabWd^k fdk[`Y fa qgeW fZW TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWWV[`Ye fa bgdUZSeW S^^ ad egTefS`f[S^^k S^^ aX fZW EWfiad]pe SeeWfe i[fZagf fZW 7efdaep Ua`eW`f)r Daf) ,46 REE AKRN ID$ Sf --) JZW Ud[f[US^ XSUfe SdW fZSf fZW EWfiad] [e ^ae[`Y _a`Wk S`V ZSe `a bdaebWUf aX fgd`[`Y fZSf Sdag`V g`VWd fZW UgddW`f YahWd`S`UW efdgUfgdW) 8gf [f [e S^ea fdgW fZSf fZW EWfiad] ZSe hS^gW) 7`V [` S XS[d S`V abW` TS`]dgbfUk

SgUf[a` Ua`VgUfWV Tk S fdgefWW' fZaeW SeeWfe iag^V Ya fa fZW Z[YZWef T[VVWd),. GWdZSbe 9a_USef CW`VWd i[^^ SUcg[dW fZW SeeWfe' S`V TW [` S bae[f[a` fa abWdSfW fZW EWfiad] XdWW aX fZW 7efdaep hWfa d[YZfe) @X fZW 7efdae hS^gW $ad S`k afZWd bSdfk hS^gWe% fZW EWfiad] _adW Z[YZ^k' fZSf bSdfk iag^V ZShW WhWdk abbadfg`[fk fa SUcg[dW fZW EWfiad]' XdWW aX 9a_USef Fi`Wdpe d[YZfe g`VWd fZW bSdf`WdeZ[b SYdWW_W`f fa WjWdU[eW Ua`fda^) JZSf agfUa_WsfZSf fZW EWfiad] X[`Ve [feW^X [` TS`]dgbfUk S`V egT\WUf fa fZW dWeg^f aX fZW TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWees[e fZW `SfgdS^ S`V aTh[age dWeg^f aX fZW EWfiad]pe [`ea^hW`Uk' iZ[UZ [` fgd` [e fZW `SfgdS^ S`V aTh[age dWeg^f aX fZW 7efdaep dWXgeS^ fa bWd_[f fZW EWfiad] fa W`fWd [`fa USdd[SYW SYdWW_W`fe Sf _Sd]Wf(U^WSd[`Y bd[UWe) =adU[`Y fZW 7efdae fa ^[hW i[fZ fZW WUa`a_[U S`V ^WYS^ Ua`eWcgW`UWe aX fZW[d eW^X([`fWdWefWV Ua__WdU[S^ VWU[e[a`e [e [` `a iSk S e[Y` aX TSV XS[fZ)

,. JZ[e S^a`W [e S Ua_b^WfW S`eiWd fa fZW 7efdaep SdYg_W`f $Daf) --% fZSf fZW [`ha^g`fSdk TS`]dgbfUk [e S` [_bdabWd YS_T[f Tk fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade fa S^^ai 9a_USef CW`VWd fa SUcg[dW fZW EWfiad] Sf faa ^ai S bd[UW)

( ,1 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 17 of 26

JZW 7efdae S^ea Ua`fW`V $Daf) ,3' -+(-,% fZSf fZW bWf[f[a` iSe X[^WV fa qU[dUg_hW`fr

^S`YgSYW [` fZW YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd SYdWW_W`f dWcg[d[`Y g`S`[_age Ua`eW`f Xad S TS`]dgbfUk X[^[`Y)

JZW 7efdae' ZaiWhWd $fa geW fZW[d ai` bZdSeW%' qUS``af ZShW [f TafZ iSke)r Daf) -. `),1) J[_W

S`V SYS[` [` fZW[d _af[a` $W)Y)' b)1%' fZW 7efdae W_bZSe[lW fZSf 9a_USef [e S ^SdYW eabZ[ef[USfWV

W`f[fk i[fZ eabZ[ef[USfWV Uag`eW^' fZSf [f XdWW^k SYdWWV fa fZW dWefd[Uf[a`e [` hSd[age SYdWW_W`fe'

S`V fZSf [f Uag^V ZShW $Tgf V[V `af% TSdYS[` Xad afZWd bdah[e[a`e) JZSf [e S^^ fdgWsS`V [f S^^

Sbb^[We i[fZ WcgS^ XadUW fa fZW 7efdae) JZW 7efdae Uag^V ZShW' Xad WjS_b^W' TSdYS[`WV Xad S

bdah[e[a` [` fZW[d Ua`fdSUfe fZSf bdaZ[T[fWV 9a_USef SXX[^[SfWe Xda_ X[^[`Y S` [`ha^g`fSdk

TS`]dgbfUk bWf[f[a`) JZWk UZaeW `af fa' [`efWSV abf[`Y Xad bdafWUf[a` a`^k SYS[`ef fZW qha^g`fSdk

X[^[`Y aX S bWf[f[a` Xad TS`]dgbfUkr Tk fZW EWfiad] [feW^X) JZSf bdah[e[a` ZSe TWW` efd[Uf^k

SVZWdWV fa ZWdW),/

Ead VaWe fZW [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` Ua`ef[fgfW S U[dUg_hW`f[a` aX fZW SYdWW_W`f' ad S

h[a^Sf[a` aX [fe qeb[d[f)r Daf) -+) @`VWWV' fZW S^^WYSf[a` [e S dW_Sd]ST^W a`W' [` h[Wi aX fZW

7efdaep ShaiWV efdSfWYk) 7e fZW[d bgT^[U bda`ag`UW_W`fe _S]W U^WSd' fZW 7efdae SdW g`ZSbbk

i[fZ fZW fWd_e aX fZW _WV[S(d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f W`fWdWV [`fa Tk fZW_ S`V fZW EWfiad] bd[ad fa fZW

UgddW`f ai`Wdpe bgdUZSeW aX fZW fWS_),0 @f [e a`^k SYS[`ef fZSf TSU]Vdab fZSf fZW 7efdaep afZWd(

,/ JZW 7efdae SdYgW $Daf) -+% fZSf [` fZSf bdah[e[a`' fZW iadV qha^g`fSdkr _aV[X[We qX[^[`Y'r S`V ZW`UW qfZW >W`WdS^ GSdf`Wd 7YdWW_W`f bdaZ[T[fe fZW X[^[`Y aX !"# bWf[f[a` Xad TS`]dgbfUk i[fZagf g`S`[_age Ua`eW`f' iZWfZWd ha^g`fSdk ad [`ha^g`fSdk)r JZSf SdYg_W`f XS[^e Xad fia [`VWbW`VW`f dWSea`e) =[def' fZW 7efdaep [`fWdbdWfSf[a` dW`VWde fZW iadV qha^g`fSdkr W`f[dW^k egbWdX^gage' q[` Ua`fdShW`f[a` aX WefST^[eZWV dg^We aX Ua`fdSUf [`fWdbdWfSf[a`)r 4AMN# 6QNOQIESAQX" /MC$ U$ )AMNM" /MC$' 0.2 =).V .4/' /++ $0fZ 9[d) -++3%) IWUa`V' fZW YW`WdS^ bSdf`Wd SYdWW_W`f e[_b^k VaWe `af T[`V fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade)

,0 9EE Bd[ef[W H[W]W`' )QAME HNOER 'RSQNR" )94 .NTRSNM CAM RSQIJE DEAK' JZW 7eeaU[SfWV GdWee' FUf) 4' -+,.' AUAIKABKE AS Zffb5**STU`Wie)Ya)Ua_*Ibadfe*i[dWIfadk*UdS`W(ZabWe(Sefdae(Ue`( Zagefa`(efd[]W(VWS^(-+0--124 $`af[`Y fZSf 7efdaep ai`Wd A[_ 9dS`W qTagYZf fZW fWS_ iZW` fZW bSdf`WdeZ[b i[fZ 9IE iSe S^dWSVk [` b^SUWr S`V fZSf 9dS`W qiag^V TW ZSbbk i[fZr S _WV[S

$n)Ua`f[`gWV%

( ,2 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 18 of 26

i[eW [`Wjb^[UST^W SUf[a`esT^aU][`Y fZW EWfiad] Xda_ W`fWd[`Y [`fa USdd[SYW SYdWW_W`fe Sf fZW _Sd]Wf(U^WSd[`Y bd[UWe' ad Xda_ SUUWbf[`Y bdabaeS^e Xad VWTf ad Wcg[fk Xg`V[`Y' WSUZ aX iZ[UZ iag^V ZShW bdah[VWV Xg`Ve fZSf Uag^V ZShW TWW` geWV fa bSk Xad fZW 7efdaep _WV[S d[YZfes_S]W eW`eW) @X a`^k fZW 7efdae Uag^V dg` fZW EWfiad] [`fa [`ea^hW`Uk' fZWk iag^V TW ST^W fa fWd_[`SfW fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f' S`V eW^^ fZW[d _WV[S d[YZfe $bWdZSbe Sf S Z[YZWd bd[UW% a` fZW abW` _Sd]Wf) 8gf fZW Ua`eWcgW`UW aX dg``[`Y fZW EWfiad] [`fa [`ea^hW`Uk [e fZSf [f bWd_[fe [fe hS^[V UdWV[fade iZa iag^V TW ^WXf g`bS[V fa X[^W S` [`ha^g`fSdk TS`]dgbfUk USeW) =ad fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade fa fS]W fZSf SUf[a`s`aiZWdW bdaZ[T[fWV Tk fZW bSdf[Wep SYdWW_W`fsXad fZW eS]W aX _Sj[_[l[`Y fZW[d dWUahWd[We [e S iZa^^k bdabWd geW aX fZW TS`]dgbfUk bdaUWee)

DadWahWd' Tk bdaZ[T[f[`Y fZW bSdf[We Xda_ X[^[`Y S ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` i[fZagf fZW 7efdaep Ua`eW`f' fZW 7efdae aTfS[`WV egTefS`f[S^ bdafWUf[a`' WhW` fZagYZ fZWk ^WXf abW` fZW baee[T[^[fk aX S` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a` Tk SXX[^[SfWe ad afZWd `a`(bSdf[We [` fZW WhW`f aX fZW EWfiad]pe [`ea^hW`Uk) 7` [`ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`' SXfWd S^^' dWcg[dWe SVV[f[a`S^ Ua`V[f[a`e fa TW _Wf $fZaeW [`

.+.$T%$,%' Xad WjS_b^W%' S`V S` adVWd Xad dW^[WX a` egUZ S bWf[f[a` dWcg[dWe fZW eSf[eXSUf[a` aX ef[^^ afZWd Ua`V[f[a`e $fZW `af(YW`WdS^^k(bSk[`Y Ua`V[f[a` [` .+.$Z%$,%' Xad [`efS`UW%) JZW 7efdae ZShW dWUW[hWV fZW Xg^^ TW`WX[f aX fZW TS`]dgbfUk(dW^SfWV bdafWUf[a` Xad iZ[UZ fZWk TSdYS[`WV' [`U^gV[`Y 9a_USef Fi`Wdpe YaaV(XS[fZ Ua_b^[S`UW i[fZ fZW ^WffWd aX fZW SYdWW_W`fpe bdah[e[a`e) 7e qS eabZ[ef[USfWV bSdfQkR dWbdWeW`fWV Tk eabZ[ef[USfWV Uag`eW^r $Daf) 1%' fZSf [e S^^ fZW 7efdae SdW W`f[f^WV fa)

@` S`k WhW`f' fZW qU[dUg_hW`f[Qa`Rr aX S `a(TS`]dgbfUk bdah[e[a` $Daf) ,4% [e `af TSV XS[fZ iZWdW' Se ZWdW' fZW X[^[`Y ZSe S ^WY[f[_SfW dWadYS`[lSf[a`S^ aT\WUf[hW) @` /M QE 1IMGRSNM

$Ua`f[`gWVn)%

d[YZfe SddS`YW_W`f fZSf [e _adW ^[]W fZW JWjSe HS`YWdep SddS`YW_W`f qiadfZ STagf !. T[^^[a` ahWd -+ kWSder%)

( ,3 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 19 of 26

9PTAQE 'RRNCIASER' -,/ 8)H) 2,. $8S`]d) I);)E)O) ,442%' Xad WjS_b^W' S^fZagYZ fZW Uagdf Xag`V fZSf qfZW ;WTfade Ua^^gVWV i[fZ fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade fa X[^W' ad adUZWefdSfW fZW X[^[`Y aX' fZWeW Q[`ha^g`fSdkR USeWe n fa U[dUg_hW`f iZSf WXXWUf[hW^k iWdW bdaZ[T[f[a`e a` fZW X[^[`Y aX ha^g`fSdk bWf[f[a`e'r ID$ Sf 2-.(-/' [f VWU^[`WV fa V[e_[ee TWUSgeW [f Xag`V fZSf fZW dW^WhS`f bSdf[Wep [`fW`f iSe qfa bdWeWdhW hS^gW Xad fZW ;WTfadep WefSfWe S`V UdWV[fade'r ID$ Sf 2.16 REE AKRN ID$ $qJZW DahS`fe _Sk XWW^ Tdg[eWV TWUSgeW fZW HWeba`VW`fe agf_S`WghWdWV iZSf fZW DahS`fe fZagYZf iSe S` [da`(U^SV bdah[e[a` n bdWhW`f[`Y S TS`]dgbfUk X[^[`Y' Tgf fZ[e VaWe `af _WS` fZSf' i[fZagf _adW' fZW bWf[f[a`e _gef TW V[e_[eeWV)r%) JZWdW [e `a egUZ Ua^^ge[a` ZWdW' Tgf WhW` [X fZWdW iWdW'' fZ[e TS`]dgbfUk USeW eWW]e fa bdWeWdhW fZW EWfiad]pe egTefS`f[S^ hS^gW' iZ[UZ [e S egXX[U[W`f TSe[e fa VW`k fZW _af[a` fa V[e_[ee)

JZW 7efdae Uag`fWd $Daf) -+% Tk U[f[`Y /M QE -KNBAK 9HIO 9XRSELR" 22)' .4, 8)H) ,4. $8S`]d) I);) >S) -++2%) 8gf fZSf USeW VaWe `af Za^V fZSf qU[dUg_hW`f[a`r S^a`W iSddS`fe V[e_[eeS^ TSeWV a` TSV XS[fZ) @`VWWV' fZW Uagdf fZWdW U[fWV 1IMGRSNM 9PTAQE [` qW_bZSe[lQ[`YR fZSf fZW XSUf fZSf S` [`ha^g`fSdk USeW [e X[^WV n fa U[dUg_hW`f n bdah[e[a`e ^[_[f[`Y fZW X[^[`Y aX S TS`]dgbfUk USeW i[fZagf Ua`eW`f aX UWdfS[` bSdf[We [e n MNS Ua`U^ge[hW Wh[VW`UW aXQR TSV XS[fZ)r

.4, 8)H) Sf -+/ $W_bZSe[e SVVWV%)

JZW 7efdae S^ea dW^k a` /M QE =ERSEQKEIGH $REE Daf) --(-.%' Tgf fZSf dW^[S`UW [e _[eb^SUWV) 7e S` [`[f[S^ _SffWd' fZW =ERSEQKEIGH Uagdf V[V `af X[`V fZSf fZW bWf[f[a` fZWdW iSe X[^WV [` TSV XS[fZ6 [f V[e_[eeWV fZW USeW [`efWSV g`VWd ,, K)I)9) t .+0$S%$,%' S bdah[e[a` fZW 7efdae ZShW g`VWdefS`VST^k VWU^[`WV fa [`ha]W $TWUSgeW aX [fe XaUge a` fZW TWef [`fWdWefe aX fZW VWTfad S`V [fe UdWV[fade%) 9EE ,/, 8)H) Sf /,) DadWahWd' fZW TSe[e Xad fZW V[e_[eeS^ iSe fZW Uagdfpe X[`V[`Y fZSf qfZWdW iSe `afZ[`Y fa TW dWadYS`[lWVr TWUSgeW qQfRZW VWTfadpe a`^k `a`(USeZ SeeWf QiSRe S hSUS`f ^af'r S`V fZSf fZW USeW iSe fZge WeeW`f[S^^k S fia(bSdfk V[ebgfW) /D$ Sf /+' /,) JZSf [e XSd Xda_ fZW

( ,4 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 20 of 26

e[fgSf[a` ZWdW5 JZW EWfiad] ZSe egTefS`f[S^ SeeWfe fZSf Uag^V TW fZW egT\WUf aX S egUUWeeXg^

dWadYS`[lSf[a`' S`V fZW USeW [`ha^hWe `af \gef 9a_USef S`V fZW 7efdae' Tgf S^ea fZW HaU]Wfe S`V

S^^ aX fZW EWfiad]pe UdWV[fade $[`U^gV[`Y fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade% S`V W_b^akWWe),1 JZ[e [e

bdWU[eW^k fZW ][`V aX USeW Xad iZ[UZ UZSbfWd ,, iSe VWe[Y`WV)

,,,! $ 46&&(44)6. 3(13*$0,;$5,10 ,4 )($4,%.(

=[`S^^k' fZW 7efdae SdYgW Sf ea_W ^W`YfZ $Daf) -0(./% fZSf fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade

US``af WefST^[eZ fZSf S egUUWeeXg^ dWadYS`[lSf[a` [e baee[T^W S`V fZge fZW USeW eZag^V TW

V[e_[eeWV) @` dWS^[fk' S dWadYS`[lSf[a` aX fZW EWfiad] [e `af a`^k baee[T^W' Tgf ^[]W^k) 7`V

S^fZagYZ fZWdW SdW S `g_TWd aX bSfZe fa dWadYS`[lSf[a` fZSf S fdgefWW Uag^V Xa^^ai' fZWdW [e a`^k

a`W bSfZ Xad fZW EWfiad] [X fZW USeW [e V[e_[eeWV5 `WSd(fWd_' X[dW(eS^W ^[cg[VSf[a`)

JZW 7efdaep SeeWdf[a` dWefe a` fZW XS^eW bdW_[eW fZSf fZW EWfiad] ZSe fia Ua`fdSUfesfZW

^[_[fWV bSdf`WdeZ[b SYdWW_W`f $qCG7r%' S`V fZW 7efdaep _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`fsfZSf SdW

WeeW`f[S^ fa fZW EWfiad]pe dWadYS`[lSf[a` Tgf US``af TW Seeg_WV ad See[Y`WV) @` XSUf' fZW X[def aX

fZaeW Ua`fdSUfe `WWV `af TW Seeg_WV ad See[Y`WV Tk fZW EWfiad] Se bSdf aX S`k dWadYS`[lSf[a`

$S`V [`VWWV US``af TW% TWUSgeW fZW EWfiad] [feW^X IR MNS A OAQSX SN IS' S`V fZW eWUa`V aX fZWeW

SYdWW_W`fe US` TW TafZ Seeg_WV S`V See[Y`WV)

,1 I[_[^Sd^k' XWi $[X S`k% aX fZW U[dUg_efS`UWe fZSf fZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f ZSe eS[V egYYWef S ^SU] aX YaaV XS[fZ SdW bdWeW`f ZWdW5

JZW VWTfad ZSe a`W SeeWf' egUZ Se S fdSUf aX g`VWhW^abWV ad VWhW^abWV dWS^ bdabWdfk)n JZWdW SdW YW`WdS^^k `a W_b^akWWe WjUWbf Xad fZW bd[`U[bS^e' ^[ff^W ad `a USeZ X^ai' S`V `a ShS[^ST^W eagdUWe aX [`Ua_W fa egefS[` S b^S` aX dW( adYS`[lSf[a` n) QJRZWdW SdW a`^k S XWi' [X S`k' g`eWUgdWV UdWV[fade iZaeW U^S[_e SdW dW^Sf[hW^k e_S^^) JZW bdabWdfk ZSe gegS^^k TWW` baefWV Xad XadWU^aegdW TWUSgeW aX SddWSdSYWe a` fZW VWTf S`V fZW VWTfad ZSe TWW` g`egUUWeeXg^ [` VWXW`V[`Y SUf[a`e SYS[`ef fZW XadWU^aegdW [` efSfW Uagdf) 7^fWd`Sf[hW^k' fZW VWTfad S`V a`W UdWV[fad _Sk ZShW bdaUWWVWV fa S efS`V(ef[^^ [` efSfW Uagdf ^[f[YSf[a`' S`V fZW VWTfad ZSe ^aef ad ZSe TWW` dWcg[dWV fa baef S Ta`V iZ[UZ [f US``af SXXadV)n JZWdW SdW ea_Wf[_We S^^WYSf[a`e aX ida`YVa[`Y Tk fZW VWTfad ad [fe bd[`U[bS^e)

/M QE 2ISSKE )QEEJ' 224 =)-V Sf ,+2.)

( -+ (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 21 of 26

$! 5C@ .DGDM@? 2<KMH@KLCDJ $BK@@G@HM

JZW a`^k bSdf[We fa fZW CG7 SdW fZW EWfiad]pe YW`WdS^ S`V ^[_[fWV bSdf`Wde) JZW EWfiad] [feW^X [e `af S bSdfk' S`V [f ZSe `a d[YZfe ad aT^[YSf[a`e g`VWd fZW SYdWW_W`f) JZWdWXadW' Seeg_bf[a` aX fZW CG7 [e `af `WUWeeSdk Xad S egUUWeeXg^ dWadYS`[lSf[a`) @` XSUf' [f [e `af WhW`

dW^WhS`f fa S egUUWeeXg^ dWadYS`[lSf[a`),2 JZWdW [e S_b^W bdWUWVW`f Xad fZW dWadYS`[lSf[a` aX ^[_[fWV S`V YW`WdS^ bSdf`WdeZ[be g`VWd UZSbfWd ,,' [`U^gV[`Y Se S dWeg^f aX Ua`fWefWV [`ha^g`fSdk

bWf[f[a`e) 9EE" E$G$' /M QE 9NKNLAS 6AQSMEQR" 2$6$' -., 8)H) ,/4 $8)7)G) -V 9[d) ,444%6 /M QE ;EW$ 8AMGEQR (AREBAKK 6AQSMEQR' /./ 8)H) .4. $8S`]d) E);) JWj) -+,+%)

JZW USeWe U[fWV Tk fZW 7efdae Va `af eZai afZWdi[eW) JZW bSdf`WdeZ[b(dW^SfWV VWU[e[a`e fZWk U[fW S^^ SVVdWeeWV fZW TS`]dgbfU[We aX OAQSMEQR' `af fZW TS`]dgbfU[We aX fZW OAQSMEQRHIOR [`

iZ[UZ fZaeW bSdf`Wde iWdW [`ha^hWV) 9EE /M QE .AQLR' ,+ 8)H) 3,2' 3,4 $8S`]d) ;) 9a^a) ,43,%6

/M QE 5[)NMMNQ' -03 =).V .4- $0fZ 9[d) -++,%6 /M QE 9TMRES *EUEKNOEQR' 14 8)H) 2,+ $8S`]d) ;)

@VSZa ,432%) 7`V fZW `a`(bSdf`WdeZ[b VWU[e[a`e fZWk U[fW e[_[^Sd^k [`ha^hWV VWTfade fZSf iWdW

bSdf[We fa fZW Ua`fdSUfe Sf [eegW) 9EE 428( U$ (IKDIRCN ! (IKDIRCN' /10 K)I) 0,. $,43/%6 -QEAS 'L$ 5OONQSTMISIER" /MC$ U$ )HEQQXDAKE ,TMDQAIRIMG" 22)' Ea) .2,3(L9G' -+,+ MC ..3-,4 $;W^) 9Z) AS`) -4' -+,+%6 /M QE 3AQSIM' ,,2 8)H) -/. $8S`]d) E);) JWj) ,44+%6 /M QE ;AXKNQ' 4,. =)-V ,+- $.V 9[d) ,44+%6 /M QE 3IQAMS )NQO$' //+ =).V -.3 $0fZ 9[d) -++1%6 /M QE ,NNSRSAQ' .-. 8)H) 011 $8S`]d) I);)E)O) -++0%6 /M QE 2IK[ ;HIMGR" /MC$' --+ 8)H) 03. $8S`]d) E);) JWj) ,443%)

%! $LMKILR /@?D< 3DBCML $BK@@G@HM

JZW 7efdaep _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f [e Ud[f[US^ fa fZW EWfiad]pe egUUWeeXg^ dWadYS`[lSf[a`) 8gf iZWfZWd fZSf SYdWW_W`f [e S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf $S`V fZge OEQHAOR `af See[Y`ST^W%

,2 8WUSgeW fZW CG7 `WWV `af $S`V Uag^V `af% TW Seeg_WV Tk S fdgefWW' fZW 7efdaep V[eUgee[a` STagf fZW `WWV Xad Ua`fdSUfe fa TW SUUWbfWV ad dW\WUfWV [` fZW[d W`f[dWfk $Daf) -3(.+% [e [ddW^WhS`f)

( -, (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 22 of 26

`WWV `af TW VWU[VWV Sf fZ[e efSYW) 7e V[eUgeeWV' fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade ZShW eagYZf fZW Sbba[`f_W`f aX S` [_bSdf[S^ fdgefWW fa W`egdW fZSf fZW EWfiad] [e dWefdgUfgdWV XS[d^k S`V Wcg[fST^k) @X Sbba[`fWV' S fdgefWW i[^^ UZaaeW fZW bdabWd bSfZ Xad fZW dWadYS`[lSf[a` aX fZW EWfiad]' S`V [f [e baee[T^W fZSf fZW bSfZ i[^^ Ua`fW_b^SfWsdSfZWd fZS` S` SeeWf eS^W [` iZ[UZ fZW 7efdaep _WV[S d[YZfe SdW See[Y`WV fa S TgkWdsS dWadYS`[lSf[a` aX fZW EWfiad] g`VWd S b^S` fZSf WXXWUf[hW^k ^WSVe fa S dWUSb[fS^[lSf[a`' Tgf afZWdi[eW ^WShWe S dWadYS`[lWV EWfiad]' egT\WUf fa `Wi ai`WdeZ[b' Se fZW 7efdaep Uag`fWdbSdfk) JZSf eUW`Sd[a iag^V [`ha^hW Seeg_bf[a` Tgf MNS

See[Y`_W`f aX fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f) 8WUSgeW fZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f W_b^ake fZW qSUfgS^'r Se abbaeWV fa fZW qZkbafZWf[US^r fWef' REE /M QE 3IQAMS )NQO$' //+ =).V Sf -0,' [f [e W`f[dW^k baee[T^W fZSf fZW 7efdae _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f Uag^V TW Seeg_WV WhW` [X [f Uag^V `af TW See[Y`WV) =gdfZWd_adW' WhW` [X fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f iWdW S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf' fZW 7efdae ZShW $[` fZW Ua`fdSUf [feW^X% iS[hWV fZW[d d[YZf fa SeeWdf fZSf fZW Ua`fdSUf US``af TW Seeg_WV ad See[Y`WV)

,) ;HE 3EDIA 8IGHSR 'GQEELEMS /R 4NS ' 6EQRNMAK 9EQUICER )NMSQACS

MZWfZWd S Ua`fdSUf [e S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf [e S cgWef[a` aX XSUf fa TW _SVW SXfWd S^^ XSUfe S`V U[dUg_efS`UWe SdW Ua`e[VWdWV) 9EE /M QE .EADPTAQSEQR *NDGE" /MC$' ,. =).V 12/' 13. $.V 9[d) ,44.%) @f [e `af Se e[_b^W Se efSf[`Y' Xad WjS_b^W' fZSf fZW Ua`fdSUf [`ha^hWe fZW geW aX S fdSVW_Sd]) 7 cg[`fWeeW`f[S^ bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf [e a`W iZWdW fZW [VW`f[fk aX fZW VWTfad bSdfk [e ea WeeW`f[S^ fa fZW Ua`fdSUf fZSf fZW `a`(VWTfad bSdfk US``af TW WjbWUfWV fa SUUWbf bWdXad_S`UW Xda_ S`k afZWd W`f[fk) 9EE /M QE ;NMQX' 2-/ =)-V /12' /13 $0fZ 9[d) ,43/% $Sffad`Wkpe Ua`f[`YW`Uk XWW W`YSYW_W`f Ua`fdSUf iSe S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf S`V fZge U^[W`fe Uag^V `af TW XadUWV fa SUUWbf bWdXad_S`UW Xda_ S` See[Y`WW Sffad`Wk%) JZSf [e `af fZW USeW ZWdW) JZW EWfiad]pe da^W g`VWd fZW 7efdae DWV[S H[YZfe 7YdWW_W`f' fa fW^WUSef ^[hW 7efdae YS_We ^aUS^^k S`V ^[UW`eW V[efd[Tgf[a` d[YZfe Xad fZW bdaYdS__[`Y eWdh[UW Ua`fS[`[`Y fZaeW YS_We

( -- (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 23 of 26

fa fZ[dV bSdf[We' Uag^V TW bWdXad_WV Tk S`k ^aUS^ fW^WUSefWd) @` XSUf' fZW 7efdae _S]W U^WSd [` fZW[d

_af[a` $Sf ,%sSe fZWk ZShW [` fZW bdWee' REE H[W]W`' RTOQA `),0 $q>[^We B[TTW' fZW fWS_#e

YW`WdS^ Uag`eW^' eS[V fZSf [X fZW TS`]dgbfUk bWf[f[a` [e fZdai` agf fZW 7efdae iag^V TW ST^W fa

fWd_[`SfW fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f i[fZ 9IE ?agefa` S`V ^[UW`eW fZW_ fa S`ka`W W^eW)r%s

fZSf fZWk iag^V e[_b^k eWW] S`afZWd TdaSVUSef bSdf`Wd [X fZW SYdWW_W`f iWdW fWd_[`SfWV),3

7VV[f[a`S^^k' fZSf fZW 7efdae qSdW fZW a`^k DS\ad CWSYgW 8SeWTS^^ fWS_ [` ?agefa`r

TW^[WhW fZSf qfZW g`[cgW' W^[fW US^[TWd aX eWdh[UW fZWk bdah[VW [e fZW cg[`fWeeW`f[S^ bWdea`S^

eWdh[UWr $Daf) .+% [e [ddW^WhS`f fa iZWfZWd fZW SYdWW_W`f [e S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf) JZW

cgWef[a` [e iZWfZWd fZW DEBSNQ [e WeeW`f[S^ fa fZW Ua`fdSUf' `af fZW `a`(VWTfad Uag`fWdbSdfk) 7e

V[eUgeeWV' fZW EWfiad]pe [VW`f[fk [e `af WeeW`f[S^ TWUSgeW fZW 7efdae US` e[_b^k X[`V S`afZWd

TdaSVUSef bSdf`Wd) 9EE /M QE ,EXKIME 6QEREMSR" /MC$' 3, 8)H) 1-.' 1-2(1-3 $8S`]d) ;) 9a^a) ,433%

$Ua`fdSUf [` iZ[UZ 9aUS(9a^SsiZaeW TdS`V [e Sf ^WSef Se qg`[cgWr S`V qW^[fWr Se fZW 7efdae

,3 JZW 7efdaep SdYg_W`f fZSf fZW _af[a` eWW][`Y fZW Sbba[`f_W`f aX S UZSbfWd ,, fdgefWW [feW^X fd[YYWde fZW[d d[YZf fa fWd_[`SfW fZW SYdWW_W`f [e Wdda`Wage) JZW =[XfZ 9[dUg[f ZSe ZW^V fZSf fZW eWUf[a` .10 WjUWbf[a`e Sbb^k a`^k gba` qS eZai[`Y fZSf fZW `a`(VWTfad bSdfkpe Ua`fdSUf i[^^ SUfgS^^k TW See[Y`WV ad fZSf fZW `a`(VWTfad bSdfk i[^^ [` XSUf TW Se]WV fa SUUWbf bWdXad_S`UW Xda_ ad dW`VWd bWdXad_S`UW fa S bSdfks[`U^gV[`Y fZW fdgefWWsafZWd fZS` fZW bSdfk i[fZ iZa_ [f ad[Y[`S^^k Ua`fdSUfWV)r /M QE 3IQAMS )NQO$' //+ =).V -.3' -/3 $0fZ 9[d) -++1%) 7TeW`f egUZ S eZai[`Y' fZW Seeg_bf[a` aX S Ua`fdSUf [e XdWW^k bWd_[ffWV) JZW 7efdae Ua`fW`V $Daf) ..% fZSf fZW 3IQAMS efS`VSdV [e _Wf TWUSgeW fZW GWf[f[a`[`Y 9dWV[fade ZShW _ahWV Xad fZW Sbba[`f_W`f aX S fdgefWW) 8gf WhW` [X S fdgefWW [e Sbba[`fWV' fZWdW [e `a dWcg[dW_W`f fZSf [f eWW] fa Seeg_W S`k Ua`fdSUf [__WV[SfW^k' S`V [f _Sk `af TW g`f[^ _gUZ ^SfWd [` fZW TS`]dgbfUk fZSf S`k [eegW dWYSdV[`Y Seeg_bf[a` iag^V Sd[eW) 8k fZSf f[_W' fZW fdgefWWpe Sbba[`f_W`f Uag^V ZShW fWd_[`SfWV' S`V' Xa^^ai[`Y S dWhWde[a` aX fZW WefSfW fa fZW EWfiad] Se VWTfad([`(baeeWee[a` g`VWd ,, K)I)9) t ,,+0' [f Uag^V TW fZW EWfiad] fZSf eWW]e S` Seeg_bf[a`) JZ[e [e S^^ XSd Xda_ UWdfS[`' aX UagdeW' Tgf fZSf [e bdWU[eW^k fZW ba[`f5 3IQAMS dWcg[dWe fZW ebWU[X[U eZai[`Y cgafWV STahW' `af \gef fZW 7efdaep ebWUg^Sf[a`) @` S`k WhW`f' WhW` fZW Seeg_bf[a` aX S Ua`fdSUf Tk S fdgefWW ZSe ea_Wf[_We TWW` bWd_[ffWV g`VWd 3IQAMSpe qSUfgS^ See[Y`_W`fr fWef) 9EE /M QE )AQDIMAK /MDTR$" /MC$' ,,1 8)H) 41/' 43, $8S`]d) I);) FZ[a ,44+% $qQ7Reeg_bf[a` aX fZW Ua`fdSUfe Tk fZW JdgefWW a` TWZS^X aX fZW WefSfW VISH OEQFNQLAMCE BX SHE *EBSNQ iag^V `af Ua`ef[fgfW S` See[Y`_W`f i[fZ[` fZW _WS`[`Y [`fW`VWV Tk t .10$U%$,%$7% ad t .10$W%$-%$7%)r $W_bZSe[e SVVWV%%)

( -. (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 24 of 26

$Daf) .+%sZ[dWV fZW VWTfad fa bda_afW S`V eW^^ [fe bdaVgUfe Sf _ge[U Ua`UWdfe dg` Tk fZW VWTfad ZW^V fa TW Seeg_ST^W%)

=[`S^^k' fZW [`U^ge[a` aX S` [`U[VW`fS^ fdSVW_Sd] ^[UW`eW [` fZW DWV[S H[YZfe 7YdWW_W`f VaWe `af' [` S`V aX [feW^X' dW`VWd fZW SYdWW_W`f S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf fZSf US``af TW Seeg_WV S`V See[Y`WV i[fZagf fZW 7efdaep Ua`eW`f) JZW bd[_Sdk [`fW^^WUfgS^(bdabWdfk d[YZfe

YdS`fWV g`VWd fZW SYdWW_W`f SdW fZW 7efdaep Uabkd[YZf [` TSeWTS^^ YS_We fZSf SdW fW^WUSef),4 JZW XSUf fZSf fZWeW fW^WUSefe i[^^ `WUWeeSd[^k [`ha^hW V[eb^Sk aX fZW 7efdaep fdSVW_Sd]e $Xad WjS_b^W' a` b^SkWdep g`[Xad_e% [e S`U[^^Sdk fa fZW _S[` bgdbaeW aX fZW Ua`fdSUf' S`V Uagdfe ZShW dW\WUfWV eWUf[a` .10 UZS^^W`YWe [` egUZ U[dUg_efS`UWe) 9EE /M QE ;NL 9SILTR )HQXRKEQ#6KXLNTSH" /MC$' ,./ 8)H) 121' 124 $8S`]d) D);) =^S) ,44,%6 /M QE 9TMQIRE 8ERS$" /MC$' ,.0 8)H) ,/4' ,0. $8S`]d) D);) =^S) ,44,%)

DadWahWd' fZW ba^[Uk TWZ[`V eWUf[a` .10pe V[eS^^aiS`UW aX Seeg_bf[a` ad See[Y`_W`f aX UWdfS[` fdSVW_Sd] ^[UW`eWe [e `af dW^WhS`f Se fa fZW [`U[VW`fS^ fdSVW_Sd] ^[UW`eW YdS`fWV Tk fZW 7efdae DWV[S H[YZfe 7YdWW_W`f) JZ[e ba^[Uk [e fZW bdafWUf[a` aX fZW fdSVW_Sd] Za^VWdpe YaaVi[^^ Xda_ _[egeW S`V [e S ]Wk bd[`U[b^W aX fdSVW_Sd] ^Si) 9EE 7TAKISEW )N$ U$ 0ACNBRNM 6QNDR$ )N$' 0,/ K)I) ,04' ,1/ $,440%) JZWdW [e `a d[e] aX egUZ _[egeW ZWdW TWUSgeW fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f bdah[VWe ebWU[X[U Yg[VW^[`We Xad ge[`Y fZW 7efdaep fdSVW_Sd]e' iZ[UZ [e bWd_[ffWV a`^k [` Ua``WUf[a` i[fZ fZW WjZ[T[f[a` aX 7efdaep YS_We S`V dW^SfWV S`U[^^Sdk geWe)

-) ;HE 'RSQNR .AUE =AIUED ;HE )KAIL ;HAS ;HE 3EDIA 8IGHSR 'GQEELEMS )AMMNS (E 'RRTLED 'MD 'RRIGMED

<hW` iWdW fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f Xag`V fa TW S bWdea`S^ eWdh[UWe Ua`fdSUf' fZW 7efdae ZShW iS[hWV S`k U^S[_ fZSf eWUf[a` .10 TSde [fe Seeg_bf[a` ad See[Y`_W`f' [`U^gV[`Y [`

,4 <jU^ge[hW Uabkd[YZf ^[UW`eWe' egUZ Se fZW a`W [` fZW 7efdae _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f' SdW XdWW^k See[Y`ST^W [` TS`]dgbfUk) 9EE /M QE -NKDEM (NNJR" -14 8)H) .++' .+4 $8S`]d) ;) ;W^) -++,%)

( -/ (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 25 of 26

TS`]dgbfUk' Tk SYdWW[`Y fa bdah[e[a`e [` fZSf Ua`fdSUf fZSf WjbdWee^k Ua`fW_b^SfW Seeg_bf[a` ad See[Y`_W`f) 9EE /M QE 3IDVAX 'IQKIMER" /MC$' 1 =).V /4-' /41 $2fZ 9[d) ,44.%6 /M QE '4) 8EMSAK )NQO$' -22 8)H) --1' -.3 `)4 $8S`]d) ;) ;W^) -++-%) @` bSdf[Ug^Sd' eWUf[a` ,-)0$9% aX fZW 7efdae DWV[S H[YZfe 7YdWW_W`f bdah[VWe Xad fZW SYdWW_W`fpe Seeg_bf[a` Tk S TS`]dgbfUk fdgefWW $S_a`Y afZWde%' ebWU[Xk[`Y UWdfS[` d[YZfe fZW 7efdae ZShW [X egUZ fdgefWW eagYZf fa ARRIGM fZW SYdWW_W`f Tgf bdah[V[`Y `a egUZ d[YZfe [` fZW WhW`f aX ARRTLOSINM S^a`W) IWUf[a` ,.)3$7%' _WS`iZ[^W' g`Ua`V[f[a`S^^k bWd_[fe See[Y`_W`f aX fZW Ua`fdSUf Tk fZW EWfiad] [` ebWU[X[WV U[dUg_efS`UWe' [`U^gV[`Y [` Ua``WUf[a` i[fZ S eS^W aX S^^ ad egTefS`f[S^^k S^^ aX fZW EWfiad]pe SeeWfe) 7`V [` IWUf[a` ,.)3$8%' fZW 7efdae Ua`eW`fWV fa S YdS`f fa 9a_USef CW`VWd aX S eWUgd[fk [`fWdWef [` fZW EWfiad]pe d[YZfe g`VWd fZW _WV[S d[YZfe SYdWW_W`f5 fZSf YdS`f Uag^V dWeg^f' [` fZW WhW`f aX S XadWU^aegdW' [` 9a_USef CW`VWd ad [fe See[Y`WW TW[`Y fZW 7efdaep Uag`fWdbSdfk g`VWd fZW Ua`fdSUf) 7f fZW hWdk ^WSef' fZWeW bdah[e[a`e VW_a`efdSfW fZSf fZW 7efdae ZShW `af _Wf fZW[d TgdVW` aX eZai[`Y fZSf fZWdW [e MN baee[T[^[fk aX S egUUWeeXg^ dWadYS`[lSf[a`)

&10&.64,10

JZW 7efdaep _af[a` fa V[e_[ee eZag^V TW VW`[WV)

( -0 (

Case 13-35998 Document 94 Filed in TXSB on 10/15/13 Page 26 of 26

;SfWV5 FUfaTWd ,0' -+,.

HWebWUfXg^^k egT_[ffWV'

 

*e* L[`UW`f I^geZWd

?aiSdV D) IZSb[da

L[`UW`f G) I^geZWd

9dS[Y >a^VT^Sff

7`VdWi Pa^^[`YWd

M@CD<H 9KJC<H G@9B<H@E>

;C7 G@G<H

?7C< 7E; ;FHH CCG

,2,2 DS[` IfdWWf

,320 GW``ek^hS`[S 7hW`gW E)M)

Ig[fW /1++

MSeZ[`Yfa`' ;)9) -+++1

;S^^Se' JWjSe 20-+,(/1-4

$-+-% 11.(1+++

$-,/% 2/.(/0++

>WadYW M) IZgefWd' Ad)

7dfZgd A) 8gd]W

IS`]Wf A) 8g^eSdS

;S`S D) IWeZW`e

M@CD<H 9KJC<H G@9B<H@E>

J[_afZk >dSg^[UZ

?7C< 7E; ;FHH CCG

;7L@I GFCB " M7H;M<CC CCG

2 Mad^V JdSVW 9W`fWd

/0+ CWj[`Yfa` 7hW`gW

-0+ >dWW`i[UZ IfdWWf

EWi Oad]' E)O) ,++,2

EWi Oad]' E)O) ,+++2

$-,-% /0+(/+++

$-,-% -.+(33++

 

( -1 (